[Code Magistrate Hearing on October 8, 2025.] [00:00:08] MEETING TO ORDER. I HAVE REVIEWED THE DOCKET. I DO NOT SEE ANY CASES THAT WOULD REQUIRE THE ENTRANCE OF AN ORDER OF RECUSAL. I'VE NOT HAD ANY EX PARTE COMMUNICATIONS WITH ANYONE REGARDING ANY OF THE CASES ON THE DOCKET. IF YOU ANTICIPATE GIVING TESTIMONY, IF YOU WOULD STAND AND BE SWORN. ARE Y'ALL GOING TO GIVE TESTIMONY? Y'ALL? IF YOU'RE NOT SURE, STAND UP AND GO AHEAD AND GET GET SWORN. YOU'LL RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND. DO YOU SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT THE TESTIMONY YOU'RE ABOUT TO GIVE IS THE TRUTH, THE WHOLE TRUTH, AND NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH, SO HELP YOU GOD? THANK YOU. IF YOU HAVE A CELL PHONE, I'D ASK YOU TO TURN IT TO VIBRATE OR TURN IT ALL THE WAY OFF. OKAY. MISS ASHMAN. GOOD MORNING, CATHERINE ASHMAN. ENFORCEMENT MANAGER. WE'LL START WITH ITEM A ON THE AGENDA. THE PROPERTY ADDRESS IS ONE, 2211. HAPPY VILLE ROAD. STARTING WITH SLIDE NUMBER TWO. THIS IS AN AERIAL VIEW TAKEN EARLIER THIS YEAR JUST FOR LOCATION PURPOSES, SHOWING IT IS IN THE UNINCORPORATED AREA, BAY COUNTY. THIS IS A HIGHWAY 231 THAT THE YOUNGSTOWN ELEMENTARY SCHOOL, HIGHWAY 388. AND THAT PROPERTY IS OUTLINED IN BLUE. THAT'S THE CLOSER UP AERIAL VIEW OF THE PROPERTY. I'M GOING TO BE DISCUSSING THIS SINGLE WIDE MOBILE HOME THAT'S CIRCLED HERE ON THE PROPERTY. AND. INVESTIGATOR EXCUSE ME, INSPECTOR SCOTT THORPE IS HERE TO PRESENT THIS CASE. MORNING, INSPECTOR THORPE, BUILDING CODE ENFORCEMENT. I'VE SUBMITTED MY CREDENTIALS FOR RECORD. ALL MY TESTIMONY AND PHOTOS ARE ALSO SUBMITTED FOR THE RECORD. ON MARCH 31ST, 2025, INVESTIGATOR RAYMOND SCOTT OBSERVED THIS PROPERTY WHILE PATROLLING THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF BAY COUNTY KNOWN AS YOUNGSTOWN. INVESTIGATOR SCOTT INSPECTED THE PROPERTY AND FOUND, IN VIOLATION OF BAY COUNTY CODE SECTION 17 DASH TWO, IN THE FORM OF AN UNFIT, UNSAFE MOBILE HOME. DERELICT VEHICLES, WATERCRAFT, PHOTOS OF PROPERTY INTRODUCED INTO EVIDENCE AS EXHIBIT A AND CONTAINED THIS CASE FILE. THESE ARE THE PHOTOS. SINGLE WIDE MOBILE HOME. PRETTY PRETTY BAD SHAPE SITTING HERE. OVERGROWTH AROUND IT. ON MARCH 31ST NOTICE VIOLATION WAS SENT CERTIFIED AND REGULAR MAIL. THE OWNER OF RECORD, JAMES F AND ROBERT F ALDERMAN, USING THE ADDRESS LISTED. PROPERTY APPRAISER DATABASE. THE NOTICE WAS DELIVERED TO RESPONDENT AND SIGNED FOR BY JAMES ALDERMAN ON APRIL 7TH, 2025. THE REGULAR MAIL WAS NOT RETURNED. APRIL 2ND. BARELY SEE THE MOBILE HOME THERE. DERELICT VEHICLES, SOME APPLIANCES, JUNK TRASH, A RYDER MOVING TRUCK, A DERELICT VESSEL, SOME OTHER JUNK AROUND THERE THAT WAS JUST TO THE RIGHT OF THE THE MOBILE HOME, WHICH WOULD BE TO THE SOUTH OF IT. SOME DEBRIS AROUND THE SHED. AN OLD BOAT TRAILER OR FRAME, SOME MORE DEBRIS. ON APRIL 7TH AND AMENDED NOTICE OF VIOLATION WAS SENT CERTIFIED REGULAR MAIL TO THE OWNER OF RECORD. LISTEN TO BAY COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER'S DATABASE NOTICE WAS DELIVERED TO RESPONDENT AND SIGNED FOR BY JAMES ALDERMAN AGAIN ON APRIL 10TH, 2025. THE REGULAR MAIL IS NOT RETURNED. ON APRIL 7TH, INVESTIGATOR SCOTT SPOKE WITH THE PROPERTY OWNER, MISTER ALDERMAN. HE STATED HE HAS HEART PROBLEMS AND IS AND IT'S DIFFICULT TO DO WORK AROUND THE PROPERTY. HE WAS ADVISED OF THE PROCESS OF THE COUNTY TO ABATE THE VIOLATION. MISTER ALDERMAN STATED THAT HE WOULD LIKE HE WOULD HE WOULD PROBABLY LIKE TO DO THAT. HERE ARE PHOTOS FROM MAY 5TH. PRETTY MUCH SAME CONDITION. THERE'S A RUSTED TRAILER AGAIN. JULY 14TH. SOME OF THE OVERGROWTH HAS BEEN REMOVED. SEE THE STATE OF THE TRAILER. DERELICT VEHICLES, WATERCRAFT AND APPLIANCES. SOME DEBRIS TO THE SOUTHWEST. THERE IS STILL THERE. ON JUNE 9TH, MISTER ALDERMAN CONTACTED INVESTIGATOR SCOTT REQUESTED THE COUNTY TO MOVE FORWARD TO REMOVE THE MOBILE HOME FROM THE PROPERTY ON JULY 24TH, COPY NOTICE OF HEARING WAS POSTED TO THE PROPERTY. AS YOU CAN SEE, THERE STILL OVERGROWTH HAS BEEN REMOVED IN FRONT OF THE MOBILE HOME. AUGUST 19TH REINSPECTION MOBILE HOME STILL SITS IN THE SAME CONDITION. ON AUGUST 21ST, 2025. NOTICE VIOLATION OF HEARING WAS SENT, CERTIFIED AND [00:05:04] REGULAR MAIL TO OWNER OF RECORD. ON AUGUST 21ST. INVESTIGATOR SCOTT SPOKE WITH ROBERT ALDERMAN, WHO IS LISTED AS THE PROPERTY APPRAISER SITE AS OWNER, AND HIS BROTHER JAMES ALDERMAN. AND HE WISHED HIS BROTHER TO HANDLE THIS CASE ON BEHALF OF OF THE HEARING. AUGUST 21ST, 2025 A NOTICE OF VIOLATION WAS SENT, CERTIFIED AND REGULAR MAIL TO THE OWNER OF RECORD AS WELL. THE NOTICES WERE DELIVERED AUGUST 25TH, 2025. THE REGULAR MAIL IS NOT RETURNED. SEPTEMBER 15TH. THE OWNER ENCUMBRANCE REPORT WAS RECEIVED. THERE'S NO ENCUMBRANCES TO NOTIFY AND ON SEPTEMBER 18TH PROPERTY STILL REMAIN. SAME CONDITION. SEPTEMBER 25TH, 2025 A COPY OF NOTICE OF HEARING IS POSTED. BAY COUNTY GOVERNMENT CENTER AND ON OCTOBER 1ST, CHECK OF BAY COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER AND TAX COLLECTOR'S DATABASE SHOWS THE PROPERTY OWNERSHIP HAS NOT CHANGED. TAXES ARE PAID IN FULL. INSPECTIONS WERE CONDUCTED BETWEEN MARCH 31ST, 2025 AND OCTOBER 1ST, 2025, AND THE PROPERTY REMAIN IN VIOLATION. AND ON OCTOBER 1ST, RE-INSPECTION WAS CONDUCTED STILL REMAINS THE SAME CONDITION. SOME OF THE OVERGROWTH HAS BEEN REMOVED FROM THE FRONT IN THIS CASE IS SCHEDULED FOR COMPLIANCE HEARING NOVEMBER 19TH, 2025 AT 1 P.M. OKAY, AND MR. THORPE, YOU DID INSPECT THIS PROPERTY ON OCTOBER 1ST. YES, I DID, MA'AM. AND YOUR PROFESSIONAL OPINION AND PROFESSIONAL OPINION, IT IS UNFIT, UNSAFE MOBILE HOME AS IT SITS. AGAIN DERELICT VEHICLES. AND NOW THERE'S A LITTLE YOU CAN SEE THE OVERGROWTH DOWN. THERE'S A MOTORCYCLE STUCK IN THE CORNER OVER THERE. THAT IS THAT THAT'S THAT TRAILER. THAT'S JUST TO THE THE PREVIOUS SLIDE. IS, IS THE SHED UNFIT UNSAFE. YES, SIR. IT JUST HAS. NO SIR. IT JUST HAS DEBRIS AROUND IT OKAY. AND TRASH. CAN IT BE ON THE PROPERTY ALONE. THERE IS A MOBILE HOME JUST TO THE RIGHT OF THAT THAT THEY ARE LIVING IN. IT'S KIND OF A IT'S A REALLY LONG PROPERTY THAT THE SINGLE WIDE COMES OUT IN THE BEGINNING. MISS ASHMAN CLICK ON THERE. YOU CAN SEE IT JUST TO THE LEFT OF THAT PHOTO WHERE THE DOT IS. AND PHOTO THREE. AND THEN THERE'S THE SHED TO THE LEFT THERE OR RIGHT IN BETWEEN THE MOBILE HOME AND GOOD MOBILE HOME AND THE UNSAFE MOBILE HOME. OKAY. ALL RIGHT. THAT'S ALL I HAVE, SIR. OKAY. SOMEONE HERE FOR THE ALDERMAN'S. COME ON UP, PLEASE, SIR. TELL US YOUR NAME AND GIVE US A GOOD MAILING ADDRESS. PLEASE. PARDON ME. GIVE US YOUR NAME AND A GOOD MAILING ADDRESS. JAMES ALDERMAN, 12 TO 11 HARRISVILLE ROAD, YOUNGSTOWN, FLORIDA 32466. OKAY. MR. ALDERMAN, DID YOU WERE YOU ABLE TO HEAR THE TESTIMONY THAT HE GAVE? NOT VERY WELL, NO. OKAY. BASICALLY THE THE PROPERTY HAS GOT THIS MOBILE HOME THAT'S BASICALLY COLLAPSING ON THE PROPERTY. IT LOOKS LIKE AND THEN SOME WHAT WE CALL DERELICT VEHICLES, THE RYDER TRUCK AND A MOTORCYCLE AND A CAR AND A BOAT. WELL, THE CAR WAS I WAS INFORMED ABOUT NOTHING ELSE. I WAS INFORMED ABOUT. AND I HAVE SINCE MOVED THE CAR AND CLEARED ALL THE PROPERTY AROUND IN FRONT OF THE MOBILE HOMES WHERE IT CAN BE TORN DOWN. OKAY, BUT I'M A HEART PATIENT AND I CAN'T, YOU KNOW, I UNDERSTAND, I UNDERSTAND. OKAY, NOW, SINCE THEY'VE GOT A GOOD PIECE OF PROPERTY OR A GOOD PRIMARY RESIDENCE ON THE THING, THEY CAN KEEP ONE DERELICT VEHICLE. IS THAT RIGHT? YES, SIR. OKAY. YOU CAN HAVE ONE. WHAT THEY CALL DERELICT VEHICLE. I ASSUME THAT YOU'RE GOING TO WANT THE CAR. YEAH, I'VE MOVED THE CAR. OKAY. ALL RIGHT. OKAY. ANYTHING YOU WANT TO ADD TO IT? NO, THAT'S. I'VE CLEARED IT, YOU KNOW, HAD IT ALL CLEARED OUT. PAID A GENTLEMAN TO CLEAR IT ALL OUT TO WHERE SOMEONE COULD GET TO IT TO TEAR IT DOWN. OKAY, ALRIGHT. BASED ON THE TESTIMONY THAT I'VE HEARD AND THE PHOTOGRAPHS I'VE SEEN INTRODUCED INTO EVIDENCE, I'M GOING TO FIND THAT THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 12211 HAPPY VILLE ROAD, IS WITHIN THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF BAY COUNTY AND THEREFORE SUBJECT TO THE PROVISIONS OF CHAPTER 17 OF THE BAY COUNTY CODE, NOTICE HAS BEEN GIVEN TO THE RESPONDENT. HE HAS APPEARED, TESTIFIED AND BEEN AFFORDED THE OPPORTUNITY TO INTRODUCE ANY EVIDENCE OR MAKE ANY COMMENTS THAT HE WANTED TO NOTICE WAS OBVIOUSLY GIVEN TO THE RESPONDENT, AS HE [00:10:05] HAS APPEARED AND HAS BEEN GIVEN BY POSTING AND OR MAIL. THERE IS A VIOLATION ON THE PROPERTY IN THE FORM OF AN UNFIT OR UNSAFE MOBILE HOME, DERELICT VEHICLES AND OR VESSELS. THERE'S SOME TRASH IN THE FORM OR APPLIANCES OUT THERE THAT CONSTITUTE A VIOLATION OF THE CODE, AND THEREFORE ALL OF THOSE ITEMS ARE SUBJECT TO ABATEMENT. THE RESPONDENT SHALL HAVE A PERIOD OF 30 DAYS IN WHICH TO BRING THE PROPERTY INTO COMPLIANCE. ONE DERELICT VEHICLE MAY CAN REMAIN ON THE PROPERTY ONLY IF THERE IS ONE REPAIRED OR STRUCTURALLY SOUND PRIMARY STRUCTURE ON THE PROPERTY, AND APPARENTLY THERE IS. IF NO PRIMARY STRUCTURE REMAINS, THEN ALL VEHICLES, BOTH DERELICT AND OPERATIONAL, HAVE GOT TO BE STORED IN AN ENCLOSED STRUCTURE OR REMOVED. THE UNFIT OR UNSAFE MOBILE HOME MUST BE ADDRESSED IN THE FOLLOWING MANNER. APPLY FOR AND OBTAIN A DEMOLITION PERMIT TO DEMOLISH THE UNFIT OR UNSAFE STRUCTURE AND ANY AND ALL PROHIBITED ACCESSORY STRUCTURES AS MAY BE DEFINED IN THE LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS, AND REMOVE THAT DEMOLITION DEBRIS. OR YOU CAN REPAIR IT IN THE FOLLOWING MANNER. SUBMIT A COMPLETE SET OF BUILDING OR A COMPLETE BUILDING APPLICATION TO THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT, AND THAT APPLICATION MUST INCLUDE THE MOBILE HOME MANUFACTURER'S SPECIFICATIONS FOR THAT SPECIFIC MODEL OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE ENGINEERING PLANS OR BLUEPRINTS TO SHOW THAT IT IS DEVIATION FROM THE ORIGINAL HOME, AND THAT WILL BE SUBMITTED TO CODE ENFORCEMENT. REPAIR OR REMODEL THE MOBILE HOME REQUIRES THAT YOU USE MATERIAL AND DESIGN EQUIVALENT TO THE ORIGINAL CONSTRUCTION. THE STRUCTURE TO BE INCLUDED WITHIN THE SCOPE OF THIS PROVISION WILL INCLUDE THE ROOF SYSTEM, WALLS SYSTEM, FLOOR SYSTEM, WINDOWS AND EXTERIOR DOORS OF THE MOBILE OR MANUFACTURED HOME, ELECTRICAL AND PLUMBING REPAIR AND REPLACEMENT SHALL REQUIRE THE USE OF MATERIALS AND DESIGN EQUIVALENT TO THE ORIGINAL CONSTRUCTION. REPAIRS HAVE GOT TO BE MADE BY A PERSON DEFINED IN SECTION 320 .82454 OF THE FLORIDA STATUTES. THEY'VE YOU'VE GOT TO SUBMIT A DETAILED ACTION PLAN TO INCLUDE TIME FRAMES OUTLINING THE NECESSARY REPAIRS TO THE STRUCTURE, TO THE CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION, AND ALL PERMITS AND MANUFACTURER SPECIFICATIONS, ENGINEERING PLANS OR BLUEPRINTS HAVE GOT TO GO THROUGH THE PLAN REVIEW PROCESS BEFORE ANY PERMIT WILL ISSUE. ALL PERMIT INSPECTIONS HAVE GOT TO BE COMPLETED BY THE BUILDER SERVICES DIVISION STAFF OR A DESIGNEE, AND THE REPAIRS HAVE GOT TO BE MADE IN ACCORD WITH THE ACTION PLAN AND STRUCTURAL REPORT. AND BUILDING PERMIT INSPECTIONS HAVE GOT TO BE COMPLETED AND PERMITS FINALIZED IN ORDER FOR THE REPAIRS TO BE DEEMED COMPLETE. IF AT ANY TIME THE PERMITS UNDER THIS ORDER EXPIRE OR BECOME VOID FOR ANY OTHER REASON, IT SHALL BE DEEMED A FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH THE TERMS OF THIS ORDER. IT'S THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE RESPONDENT TO CONTACT AND INFORM CODE ENFORCEMENT OF ANY PROGRESS OR DELAYS IN BRINGING THE PROPERTY INTO COMPLIANCE. IF THE RESPONDENT FAILS TO COMPLY WITH THE ABOVE ACTIONS FROM THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF THIS ORDER, I'M GOING TO WAIVE THE FINE IN LIGHT OF THE FACT THAT HE'S ALREADY CLEARED THE PROPERTY TO FACILITATE THE REMOVAL OF THE MOBILE HOME. THE THE COST OF THE ABATEMENT SHALL BE SUBJECT OF A SEPARATE HEARING AND WILL BE BECOME A LEAN UPON THE REAL AND PERSONAL PROPERTY OWNED BY THE RESPONDENTS IN BAY COUNTY. THE NONCOMPLIANCE WOULD ALSO BE DEEMED TO HAVE OCCURRED IF THE RESPONDENT WERE TO OBTAIN A DEMOLITION OR A BUILDING PERMIT WITHIN THE TIME FRAME SET FORTH, AND THEN ALLOWS THAT PERMIT TO EXPIRE OR HAS BECOME VOID FOR ANY OTHER REASON THAT ALL WILL BE DEEMED A DEFAULT. COMPLIANCE HEARING IN THIS MATTER IS SET FOR NOVEMBER THE 19TH AT 1 P.M. AND THAT WILL BE IN THIS. WE'RE STILL IN THIS BUILDING AT THAT POINT, OKAY. IN LIGHT OF THE FACT THAT YOU'VE ANNOUNCED THAT YOU WANT THE COUNTY TO TAKE IT DOWN AND EVERYTHING, CAN Y'ALL GO AHEAD AND START DOING THE [00:15:02] PRE INSPECTIONS AND ALL OF THAT SORT OF STUFF SO WE CAN YES, YES, MOVE ON ON THAT CASE. ALRIGHT. ON NOVEMBER THE 19TH WHAT WE'LL BE DOING IS THEY WILL COME BACK AND THEY SAY OKAY THE TIME HAS LAPSED AND THE BUILDINGS OR THE MOBILE HOMES STILL THERE AND THE DERELICT VEHICLES AND BOATS AND ALL THAT STUFF IS STILL THERE AND WE'RE GOING TO GO AHEAD AND CLEAN ALL THAT SORT OF STUFF UP. IF THERE'S SOMETHING THAT THAT YOU WANT TO TAKE OUT OF THERE BY YOURSELF TO HELP REDUCE THE COST OF THE ACTUAL CLEANUP, YOU GO AHEAD AND DO THAT AS SOON AS YOU CAN. SO THAT WON'T BE INCLUDED IN THE BID. WHEN THEY HAVE THE CONTRACTOR COME UP OR CONTRACTORS COME UP AND BID THE JOB. OKAY. ALL RIGHT. LIKE I SAID ON THE 19TH, THEY'LL TELL ME WHETHER OR NOT IT'S CLEAN OR NOT. AND THEN AT THAT POINT I'LL, I'LL GO AHEAD AND ORDER THE THEM TO PROCEED IF IT'S NOT CLEANED UP. ALL RIGHT. WELL WE'LL SOMEONE COME OUT AND GIVE ME LET ME KNOW WHAT WHAT THEY'RE DOING AS FAR AS REMOVING STUFF BECAUSE THE BOAT, THE BIG BOX TRAILER THAT'S THERE, THAT'S, THAT'S FULL OF STORAGE. IT'S. WELL, THERE'LL BE UP THERE IN THE MEANTIME TO TO TO BID IT, BUT THEY'RE NOT GOING TO BE, YOU KNOW, TELLING YOU EVERY MOMENT AND EVERYTHING. AND THEN YOU'LL GET A NOTICE AFTER WE HAVE THIS HEARING ON THE 19TH AS TO THEY'RE GOING TO MOVE FORWARD WITH THE, WITH THE CLEANUP. SO IF YOU'RE, IF YOU WANT ANYTHING OUT OF THAT BOX TRUCK, YOU NEED TO START MOVING IT AS SOON AS POSSIBLE. SO THE BOX TRUCK CAN'T BE LEFT THERE. WELL, YOU GET ONE DERELICT VEHICLE ON THE PROPERTY. I DON'T KNOW WHETHER THE THE CAR. DID YOU TAKE THE CAR? SLAM OFF. THE PROPERTY IS MOVED. YES. OKAY. YOU CAN'T MOVE IT TO THE OTHER PART OF THE PROPERTY AND THEN MOVE THE BOX TRUCK OR KEEP THE BOX TRUCK ON THERE AND ONLY GET ONE DERELICT VEHICLE, WHETHER IT BE THE CAR OR THE BOX TRUCK OR WHATEVER. SO IF YOU WANT TO KEEP THAT BOX TRUCK AS THE DERELICT VEHICLE, YOU, THAT'S THE ONLY ONE THAT YOU CAN HAVE ON THE PROPERTY. OKAY, OKAY. SO WHEN THEY COME UP TO BID IT, YOU CAN TALK WITH THEM ABOUT, YOU KNOW, WHAT'S GOING TO GO AND WHAT'S GOING TO STAY. ALL RIGHT. ALL RIGHT. AND THAT'LL BE BEFORE THE 19TH. I DON'T KNOW WHEN THAT WILL BE. THAT'S OCTOBER 22ND WILL BE BIDS OKAY. OCTOBER THE 22ND. OKAY. I'LL COME DOWN. KNOCK ON YOUR DOOR. PARDON ME. I'LL KNOCK ON YOUR DOOR WHEN WE COME UP THERE. ALL RIGHT. THAT'LL WORK. OKAY. MR. ALDERMAN, THIS LADY HAS A QUESTION FOR YOU. DO YOU WANT YOUR MAIL TO GO TO THE P.O. BOX OR TO THE HAPPY VILLAGE, P.O. BOX 227, SOUTH FLORIDA? YES, SIR. OKAY. THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. WE APPRECIATE IT. ALL RIGHT. YOU ALL HAVE A WONDERFUL DAY. YOU TOO. ALL RIGHT. THERE'S A DOG AND DOG. ITEM C HAS COME IN LATE. OKAY. JUST TO LET YOU KNOW THAT WE'LL CONTINUE ON WITH D, RIGHT. EVERY ADDRESS IS 6114 EAST SIXTH STREET. FIRST SLIDE IS THIS AERIAL VIEW TAKEN EARLIER THIS YEAR TO SHOW THAT IT IS IN THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF BAY COUNTY. CALLOWAY AREA. THIS IS THE PROPERTY CIRCLED IN RED HIGHWAY 22. CALLOWAY ELEMENTARY SCHOOL. CLOSER UP. AERIAL VIEW OF THE PROPERTY. AND I'M GOING TO LET INVESTIGATOR BRUENING TALK ABOUT WHICH STRUCTURES WE'RE GOING TO BE DISCUSSING TODAY. OKAY. YOU GOT TWO UNFIT, UNSAFE MOBILE HOMES. STRUCTURE A AND STRUCTURE B, STRUCTURE B I'LL GO THROUGH IT. BUT STRUCTURE B HAS SINCE BEEN REMOVED. STRUCTURE C IS AN ACCESSORY STRUCTURE. IS THE ACCESSORY STRUCTURE OKAY. OKAY. GOOD MORNING. MAGISTRATE, I SUBMITTED MY INVESTIGATIVE REPORT NOTICES AND PHOTOS FOR THE RECORD ON MARCH THE 4TH, 2025. INVESTIGATOR ROBERT CLARKSON OBSERVED THIS PROPERTY WHILE PATROLLING AN UNINCORPORATED AREA, BAY COUNTY. HE INSPECTED THE PROPERTY AND FOUND, IN VIOLATION OF BAY COUNTY CODE SECTION 17 TWO, IN THE FORM OF TWO UNFIT, UNSAFE MOBILE HOMES AND UNFIT, UNSAFE ACCESSORY STRUCTURE. DERELICT VEHICLES, JUNK, TRASH AND DEBRIS. PHOTOGRAPHS OF THE PROPERTY ARE INTRODUCED INTO EVIDENCE AS EXHIBIT A AND CONTAINED IN THIS CASE FILE. AND THIS IS SOME OF INVESTIGATOR CLARKSON'S YOU GOT A DERELICT VEHICLE THE RED EXPEDITION. THERE'S A TRAILER BEHIND IT, A UTILITY TRAILER, THE MOBILE HOME TO THE RIGHT IS [00:20:06] GOING TO BE THAT FRONT STRUCTURE A UNFIT, UNSAFE MOBILE HOME. YES, THE THE SHED STRAIGHT BACK IS GOING TO BE THE ACCESSORY STRUCTURE THAT'S UNFIT, UNSAFE. YOU GOT ANOTHER TRAILER ON THAT SIDE OF THE PROPERTY WITH A BUNCH OF, I DON'T KNOW, STUFF IN IT. IS THAT FENCE LINE. IS THAT A SEPARATE PIECE OF PROPERTY ON THIS SIDE OF IT? IT'S ALL ONE, ALL ONE PROPERTY. AND ON MARCH 5TH, AN INSPECTION WAS CONDUCTED BY SCOTT THORPE. AGAIN MAGISTRATE INSPECTOR THORPE, AS AN INVESTIGATOR, SAID TWO SINGLE WIDE MOBILE HOMES SIT ON THERE BE HAS BEEN REMOVED. SEE WOULD BE THE ACCESSORY STRUCTURE WHICH THEY DO HAVE A DEMOLITION PERMIT. THEY GOT ON NINE 1225 EXPIRATION OF THREE 1226. THIS IS A SINGLE WIDE THAT SITS UP FRONT. IT WAS OCCUPIED AT THE TIME. EXPOSED WIRING ON THE OUTSIDE, MISSING BULBS, THE DOORS ON THE BACK AND THE WALL. THE SHEETINGS RIPPED OFF. IT'S BEEN BOARDED OVER IN SEVERAL AREAS. WINDOW MISSING ON THE THE GABLE END THERE OR THE END OF THE MOBILE HOME. BUT SEVERAL AREAS OF THE SIDING ARE DETACHED AND BEEN SCREWED BACK DOWN IN AREAS. ANOTHER WINDOW ON THIS SIDE IS MISSING OR BOARD AND BOARDED UP. AS WE GET CLOSER. YOU CAN SEE THEY USE SPRAY FOAM TO COVER THE VOIDS. FILL THE VOIDS OF THE THE WINDOW THAT'S BEEN DETACHED FROM THE WALL FACE. AS WE GO BACK. ANOTHER WINDOW BOARDED UP. DETACHED SIDING, AND THERE'S A LITTLE CLOSER VIEW OF THE HOLE THAT WAS INSIDE OF THE MOBILE HOME ON THE BACK SIDE OF IT. AS WE GET AROUND, YOU CAN SEE THE THIS IS THE SIDE FACING THE THE ROAD. THE RIM JOIST IS ROTTED OUT. SOME OF THE WALL STUDS ARE ROTTED OUT. THE MAJORITY OF INSULATION THE UNDERLAYMENT FOR UNDERNEATH IS COLLAPSED HAS BEEN REMOVED. AND YOU CAN SEE JUST PAST THAT BLACK WIRE AND SLIDE 15 THERE AS THE WALL PROTRUDES OUTWARD FROM DECAY. AN EXTENSION CORD IT IS. IS IT HOT? YES. THERE'S A CLOSER VIEW. THEY USE SOME HOUSEWRAP TO CLOSE THE WINDOW OFF. AGAIN. MORE SIDING PULLED OFF. EXPOSED WALL SHEETING OR WALL STUDS UNDERNEATH. RIM JOIST. MISSING UNDERLAYMENT PULLED DOWN. IT'S A BETTER VIEW FROM THE FRONT THERE OF ALL THE MISSING UNDERLAYMENT AND INSULATION. THE ROOF'S GOT DEFLECTION IN IT AS WELL. THIS OTHER GABLE SIDE OTHER END OF THE MOBILE HOME. IT'S JUST EXTERIOR SHEETING ON THERE WHICH IS NOT APPROVED FOR FINAL WEATHER RESISTANCE BARRIER. IT'S ALSO STARTING TO DECAY IN THE CORNERS AND EVERYTHING. STRUCTURE B APPARENTLY HAS BEEN REMOVED. IT'S SINGLE WIDE MOBILE HOME THAT SITS BACK THERE. IT'S A LITTLE HARD. IT'S GOT THE TARP ON IT THERE. NEXT SLIDE. THERE IT IS. APPARENTLY THAT'S BEEN REMOVED. CORRECT. OKAY. SO WE'LL JUST KIND OF GO THROUGH HERE REAL QUICK. THAT WAS WAS THAT STRUCTURE. THAT WAS WE'RE GOING TO GET TO THAT ONE OKAY. OKAY. THAT IS THAT IS A THAT'S THE SHED THAT THEY HAVE FOR RENTS FOR OBVIOUSLY IT HAS HAS ROOF DAMAGE AND IT'S KIND OF ATTACHED TO THE BACK OF THE MOBILE HOME AS WELL. THAT'S THAT'S WHAT MY QUESTION WAS. WAS IT ATTACHED. BUT THEY DO HAVE ACTIVE PERMITS FOR IT. SO BUT THIS THAT MOBILE HOME IS GONE. STRUCTURE C WHICH WOULD BE THE LARGE METAL SHED AND METAL AND WOOD SHED ROOF ROOFING HAS BEEN DONE ON IT. I'M PERMITTED. BUT WE CAN KIND OF GO THROUGH THIS REAL QUICK. MISSING ONE OF THE WALLS EXPOSED, WALLING OPEN WALLS FOR UPLIFTING WINDS TO DAMAGE THE ROOF, FURTHER. JUNK AND TRASH EVERYWHERE. IT'S IT'S PRETTY, PRETTY SOLID OF A JUNKYARD BACK THERE AND SCRAPS. BUT THEY DO HAVE A PERMIT FOR IT FOR DEMOLITION. SO OKAY. AS THEY SIT THEY ALL THREE UNFIT UNSAFE. BUT ONE B HAS BEEN REMOVED. OKAY. SO THAT BASICALLY THE ONLY THING THAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT IS A YES. WELL WE ARE TALKING ABOUT A AND C BECAUSE IF THEY DO NOT FULFILL THE REMOVAL OF C WE WILL. OKAY. BUT THEY THEY'VE GOT A PERMIT, THE PERMIT WINDOW SO TO SPEAK. OKAY. RIGHT. ANYTHING ELSE FROM YOU MAY 5TH. OH SORRY. THIS IS SOME OF INVESTIGATOR CLARKSON'S PHOTOS. THERE'S. THAT'S THE MOBILE HOME IN THE BACK WITH THE ACCESSORY BEHIND IT. [00:25:10] DERELICT VEHICLE, BOAT TRAILERS. JUNK. TRASH. ALL RIGHT. ON MARCH 19TH, 2025, A NOTICE OF VIOLATION WAS SENT CERTIFIED REGULAR MAIL TO THE OWNER OF RECORD USING THE ADDRESS 6112 EAST SIXTH STREET, PANAMA CITY, FLORIDA. 3244. THE CERTIFIED NOTICE WAS DELIVERED TO THE RESPONDENT ON MARCH 22ND, 2025. A NOTICE OF VIOLATION WAS SENT, CERTIFIED AND REGULAR MAIL TO JACK WAGES USING ADDRESS 6114 EAST SIXTH STREET, PANAMA CITY, FLORIDA. 32404. THE CERTIFIED NOTICE RETURNED UNCLAIMED. THE REGULAR MAIL DID NOT RETURN. THIS PARCEL DOES HAVE TWO DIFFERENT ADDRESSES. THE ONE WE'RE DEALING WITH, 6114, BUT THE THE PROPERTY OWNER WHOSE NAME IS ON THE THE DEED IS IS 6112. OKAY. ON MARCH 25TH, 2025, JOE WAGES CALLED BAY COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT TO ADVISE. HE WAS THE SON OF THE PROPERTY OWNER AND WOULD ADDRESS THE VIOLATIONS. ON APRIL 3RD, 2025, DEMOLITION PERMIT WAS ISSUED FOR ONE OF THE MOBILE HOMES. THAT PERMIT EXPIRED ON OCTOBER 3RD, 2025. ON MAY 5TH, 2025, I WAS ASSIGNED THIS CASE. I INSPECTED THE PROPERTY AND IT REMAINED IN VIOLATION. JUNE THE 9TH, 2025. WE INSPECTED THE PROPERTY. IT REMAINED IN VIOLATION DURING THIS INSPECTION. YOU CAN SEE THAT THE THE ONE MOBILE HOME HAS BEEN REMOVED. IT'S IT WAS SET BETWEEN THE FRONT MOBILE HOME AND THE ACCESSORY. YOU STILL GOT JUNK TRASH, DEBRIS. THAT'S PART OF THE THE FRONT MOBILE HOME. THE BOAT, THE DERELICT VEHICLE, THE TRAILER. AUGUST 20TH, 2025 I INSPECTED THE PROPERTY. THERE'S BEEN SOME FORWARD MOVEMENT AS FAR AS CLEANUP. IT APPEARS THEY'RE WORKING ON THE ACCESSORY BACK THERE. THAT'S PART OF THE FRONT MOBILE HOME. AND THERE'S THE DERELICT VEHICLES TRAILERS. ON AUGUST 21ST, 2025, NOTICE OF VIOLATION, NOTICE OF HEARING WAS SENT, CERTIFIED AND REGULAR MAIL TO THE OWNER OF RECORD USING THE ADDRESS. 6112 EAST SIXTH STREET, PANAMA CITY, FLORIDA 32404. NEITHER NOTICE RETURNED. A NOTICE OF VIOLATION NOTICE HEARING WAS ALSO SENT CERTIFIED REGULAR MAIL TO JACK WAGES USING ADDRESS 6114 EAST SIXTH STREET, PANAMA CITY, FLORIDA. THE CERTIFIED NOTICE WAS RETURNED UNCLAIMED. THE REGULAR MAIL DID NOT RETURN. AUGUST 27TH, 2025 I SPOKE WITH JOE WAGES BY TELEPHONE. HE ADVISED. THE MOBILE HOME IN THE FRONT OF THE PROPERTY WAS OWNED BY INDIVIDUAL BY THE NAME OF PAMELA BRANNON, WHO CURRENTLY LIVES IN THAT MOBILE HOME. A COPY OF THE NOTICE OF VIOLATION NOTICE WAS SENT, CERTIFIED AND REGULAR MAIL TO PAMELA BRANNON USING THE ADDRESS. 6114 EAST SIXTH STREET, PANAMA CITY, FLORIDA. 3344. THE CERTIFIED NOTICE RETURNED UNCLAIMED. THE REGULAR MAIL DID NOT RETURN. SEPTEMBER 9TH, 2025 I SPOKE WITH CRYSTAL O'MARA, WHO'S THE GRANDDAUGHTER OF THE PROPERTY OWNER. SHE ADVISED SHE IS WORKING TO CORRECT ALL THE VIOLATIONS. SHE ALSO ADVISED PAMELA BRANNON WAS NOT COOPERATING WITH THE VIOLATION CONCERNING HER MOBILE HOME, WHICH IS THE MOBILE HOME. SEPTEMBER 12TH, 2025 A DEMOLITION PERMIT WAS ISSUED FOR THE ACCESSORY STRUCTURE. THAT PERMIT WILL EXPIRE ON MARCH 12TH, 2026. SEPTEMBER 25TH. THE PROPERTY WAS POSTED AS WELL AS BAY COUNTY GOVERNMENT CENTER. OCTOBER THE 6TH, 2025. I INSPECTED THE PROPERTY AND THEY'RE STILL WORKING ON THE ACCESSORY STRUCTURE. I GUESS THEY GOT SOME OF THEIR ITEMS UP UNDER THAT WITH PLASTIC OR SOMETHING OVER IT. THEY STILL GOT A WAYS TO GO TO BRING THIS PROPERTY IN [00:30:03] COMPLIANCE. THE THE STUFF ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THE PROPERTY HADN'T BEEN MOVED OR TOUCHED. THIS CASE IS SCHEDULED FOR COMPLIANCE HERE ON NOVEMBER 19TH, 2025 AT 1 P.M. HAVE YOU HEARD ANYTHING FROM THIS, BRANNON? NOT A WORD. OKAY. AND IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING. THE DAY I POSTED RIGHT BESIDE HER MAILBOX, I DIDN'T GET FAR DOWN THE ROAD AND SHE SNATCHED THAT POSTING UP. OKAY. ALL RIGHT. SO SHE KNOWS ABOUT IT. OKAY. ALL RIGHT. WHO'S HERE ON BEHALF OF THIS PROPERTY? ALL RIGHT. GOOD MORNING. GOOD MORNING. MY NAME IS JOE. AND GIVE US A GOOD MAILING ADDRESS JOE WAGES 6114 EAST SIXTH STREET. THAT'S WHERE MY MOTHER LIVES AT. YOU CAN SEND ALL THE INFORMATION TO HER. OKAY? I AM THE ONE IN THE PROCESS OF CLEANING THIS MESS UP. TRYING MY BEST. I SAID I DONE TORE DOWN THAT ONE TRAILER THAT'S RIGHT BESIDE THE MY OPINION POLL BARN SLASH SHED, WHICH I'M IN THE PROCESS OF TEARING DOWN THAT POLE BARN SLASH SHED TOO. OKAY, WELL, MORE THAN HALF THROUGH WITH IT AND I AM CLEANING UP THE YARD AND STUFF TOO, YOU KNOW, LIKE I TOLD HIM, WE DON'T OWN THE TRAILER. PAM BRANDON OWNS THE TRAILER, SO I CAN'T VERY WELL DO NOTHING WITH THAT. OKAY? AND SHE KNOWS SHE'S IN VIOLATION. SHE'S BEEN TOLD SHE'S THE ONE YANKED THE SIGN UP, CARRIED IT INSIDE. OH, MY CONCERN IS I'M CLEANING ALL THE OTHER STUFF UP, AND I'LL HAVE THE THE THE POLE BARN SLASH SHED TORE DOWN HERE SHORTLY AND YARD CLEANED UP. I'M IN THE PROCESS OF GOING TO MOVE THAT BOAT AND THAT VEHICLE. I THINK HE'S WANTING TO GET RID OF IT. SO AND THAT OTHER TRAILER, THEY'RE LOADED DOWN WITH CRAP. SOMEBODY SAID THAT THEY WANTED THAT. SO THAT SHOULD BE GONE HERE SHORTLY TO. BUT MY CONCERN IS WITH THE TRAILER THAT PAM BRANDON'S LIVING IN. I CAN'T DO NOTHING WITH IT. AND I DON'T FEEL LIKE MY MOTHER SHOULD BE RESPONSIBLE FOR TEARING IT DOWN. AND WE CAN'T TO BEGIN WITH, BECAUSE IT AIN'T OURS. I DON'T WANT HER TO HAVE A LIEN PUT AGAINST HER PROPERTY FOR A TRAILER THAT DON'T BELONG TO HER, RIGHT. I THINK PAM BRANDON SHOULD BE RESPONSIBLE FOR TEARING IT DOWN. YOU KNOW, I'LL TAKE CARE OF ALL THE REST, BUT I CAN'T TAKE CARE OF THE TRAILER THAT SHE'S LIVING IN. BUT I DID GET WORD THAT SHE'S IN THE PROCESS OF MOVING OUT, BUT OKAY, MY CONCERN IS, IS IS SHE GOING TO TAKE RESPONSIBILITY FOR HER TRAILER? THAT SHE MIGHT JUST LEAVE THERE? NOW, I DID GIVE I THINK THIS MAN WAS SENT A COPY OF A PIECE OF PAPER WHERE SHE'S CLAIMING THE TRAILER BELONGS TO HER. YOU KNOW, I, I CAN'T PROVE THAT THE TRAILER BELONGS TO HER, OTHER THAN THE PIECE OF PAPER THAT I GOT. IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO SEE IT, I. YES, SIR, I WOULD PRESENT IT. BUT SHE'S CLAIMING RESPONSIBILITY OF THE TRAILER RIGHT HERE, SO I WOULD LIKE FOR HER TO TAKE CARE OF THE COST OF REMOVING IT. I UNDERSTAND THAT, I UNDERSTAND I CAN TAKE CARE OF EVERYTHING ELSE, BUT I CAN'T TAKE CARE OF THAT TRAILER BECAUSE IT DON'T BELONG TO ME. BUT SHE IS IN THE PROCESS OF MOVING. THAT'S WHAT I WAS INFORMED. WE HAVE NOT SAW IT, WE WERE JUST INFORMED. BUT I WOULD HATE TO THINK THAT MY MOTHER IS GOING TO BE RESPONSIBLE FOR THE REMOVAL OF THAT TRAILER WHEN IT'S NOT HERS. WELL, NOW SHE'S CLAIMING MORE THAN THE TRAILER. EXACTLY, BUT SHE'S A LITTLE LOONY IN THE HEAD. SHE DON'T OWN THE PROPERTY, AND IT'S NEVER BEEN IN HER NAME. IT'S WENT FROM MY GRANDFATHER'S TO MY GRANDMOTHER'S. IT'S NEVER WENT TO ANYBODY ELSE'S NAME. THE DEATH OF MY GRANDFATHER. IT WAS STATED IN HIS THAT IT GOES STRAIGHT TO MY GRANDMOTHER. IT HAS NEVER BEEN IN ANYBODY ELSE'S NAME BUT THOSE TWO PEOPLE. YEAH, I SEE WHAT YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT THERE. THAT JUST PROVES THAT SHE AIN'T ALL THERE. WHAT IS YOUR RELATIONSHIP, JOE WAGES, WHICH IS MY MOTHER. MY MOTHER? I'M SORRY. YEAH. TO PAMELA, I'M NO RELATIONSHIP TO HER. OKAY? MY BROTHER AT ONE POINT WAS SEEING HER. HIS GIRLFRIEND. RIGHT? THAT'S THE REASON SHE'S BEEN LIVING THERE ALL THESE YEARS. AND SHE DON'T PAY RENT OR NOTHING. SHE'S JUST LIVING THERE RENT FREE. AND A TRAILER THAT BELONGS TO HER COURTESY. THAT MY MOTHER BEEN LETTING HER DO THAT. I MEAN, BUT SHE DON'T PAY RENT OR NOTHING, AND THE TRAILER [00:35:01] BELONGS TO HER, SO WE CAN'T TEAR IT DOWN. AND THAT'S THE OTHER CONCERN WE HAVE IS, YOU KNOW, YOU DEEMED IT UNLIVABLE, BUT YOU DIDN'T CONDEMN IT, WHICH MEANS THAT THAT THE ELECTRICITY CANNOT LEGALLY BE TURNED OFF UNLESS IT IS CONDEMNED. AND WE CAN'T. IT'S BECAUSE IT'S IN MY GRANDMOTHER'S NAME, THE ELECTRICITY. WE CANNOT LEGALLY TURN ANYTHING OFF UNTIL THAT HOUSE IS CONDEMNED, BECAUSE WE'LL GET IN TROUBLE FOR TURNING ELECTRICITY OFF TO SOMEONE'S HOUSE. AND THAT WAS THE OTHER CONCERN. I NEED TO KNOW IF, WHEN AND IF I CAN TURN THAT OFF SO SHE WILL GET OUT. BUT I DON'T WANT TO GET MYSELF OR MY GRANDMOTHER IN TROUBLE BY TURNING SOMETHING OFF THAT WE ARE NOT ALLOWED TO DO. HAVE. HOW BAD DOES IT HAVE TO BE BEFORE Y'ALL CAN SAY I'M GOING TO SAY SUPER UNSAFE, PLEASE COME OFF THE POWER. THE STRUCTURAL ASPECT PART OF IT IS NOT GOING TO DETERMINE THROUGH FPL OR CO-OP FOR POWER DISCONNECT. NOW IF THERE WAS UNSAFE ELECTRICAL CONNECTIONS, I COULD HAVE THE BUILDING OFFICIAL REMOVE IT JUST FROM DOCUMENTATION, BUT IT'S JUST AN EXTENSION CORD GOING THROUGH THE WINDOW. I COULDN'T. THE COUNTY WILL DISCONNECT POWER THE DAY AFTER WE DO PRE-BID WHEN WE GET TO THAT POINT, SO THEY WOULDN'T HAVE TO WORRY ABOUT IT IF IT GOT TO THAT POINT. SO OKAY. ALL RIGHT. I ASK ANOTHER QUESTION. OKAY. HOW DID THE SO. I'M A LITTLE CONFUSED ON HOW THE MOBILE HOME GOT ON THE PROPERTY. MOBILE HOME WAS GIVEN PERMISSION TO PUT THERE OVER 30 YEARS AGO. OKAY. AT THAT TIME, MY BROTHER AND THIS WOMAN WAS SEEING ONE ANOTHER. OKAY. BUT THIS PAPER THAT THAT YOU HAVE PRESENTED HAS GOT A 2013 CASE NUMBER ON IT FROM. IT LOOKS LIKE COUNTY COURT. I CAN'T SEE ALL OF IT. SO I ASSUME THAT THERE WAS SOME SORT OF EVICTION ACTION OR SOMETHING BACK IN 2013. AT THAT POINT, MY MOTHER WAS CONSIDERING. EVICTING HER, BUT AND SOMEWHERE ALONG THE LINE, MY BROTHER TALKED HER INTO LETTING HER CONTINUE STAYING. OKAY, WELL, I MEAN. CAN WE MAKE A COPY OF THIS FOR THE FILE? A COPY OF THAT WAS SENT TO TO THE MAN THAT THE CODE ENFORCEMENT MAN, A COPY OF THAT I REMEMBER, OR SOMEBODY ELSE HAD THE CASE PRIOR TO YOU AND IT WAS SENT TO. YEAH, I'M THE ONE. I'M THE ONE THAT EMAILED THAT COPY WAS SENT TO A TONI BRUNER. YEAH. THAT'S HIM. YEAH. YEAH. OKAY. I'M THE ONE THAT EMAILED YOU. SO DO YOU REMEMBER HAVING SEEN IT? I'M LOOKING. OKAY, OKAY. I CAN TELL YOU WHAT EMAIL IT WAS SENT FROM TO IT WAS SENT FROM MY EMAIL. AND THEN WHAT WAS YOUR NAME? FOR THE RECORD, MY NAME IS CRYSTAL O'MARA. I'M THE GRANDDAUGHTER OF THE. YEAH, WE'D BE MORE THAN GLAD TO SEE THAT TRAILER GONE. AND WE HAVE BEEN. IT'S JUST THERE'S NOTHING WE CAN DO, BUT I JUST I JUST DON'T FEEL LIKE MY MOTHER SHOULD BE RESPONSIBLE FOR THE BILL OF REMOVING IT. AND I UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU'RE SAYING ON THAT. YOU KNOW? THE EMAIL IT WAS SENT FROM IS IT SAYS IT'S THE EMAIL ADDRESS IS CRYSTAL G MARTIN AT YAHOO.COM. THAT'S WHERE IT WAS SENT FROM. OKAY. LET'S I WANT TO MAKE A COPY OF THAT FOR SURE. TO PUT IN THE FILE. OKAY. OKAY. ANYTHING ELSE. YES, SIR. I KNOW IT'S KIND OF ODD FOR ME TO ASK, BUT MY BROTHER WANTED TO ASK IF HE COULD KEEP THE FLOOR. THAT OLD BARN SLASH SHED. WHAT? THE FLOOR? WELL, IT'S JUST LIKE IT LOOKS LIKE IT'S MADE OUT OF TWO BY SIX. IT'S A TWO BY SIX FLOOR IN THAT SHED. IT'S PERFECTLY GOOD. TUBA. SIXTH FLOOR. AND HE JUST WANTED ME TO ASK IF HE COULD KEEP THE FLOOR. I DON'T HAVE A I MEAN, I WOULDN'T THAT'S NOT A STRUCTURE AT THAT POINT, IS IT. RIGHT. IT JUST KIND OF A FREE FLOATING DECK IS IT POSES AS LONG AS IT POSES NO HAZARD TO ANYBODY WALKING ON THE PROPERTY. I MEAN, I, I DON'T HAVE A PROBLEM WITH IT, BUT I MEAN, I JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT IT IT DOESN'T CONSTITUTE A STRUCTURE WITHIN THE MEANING OF WHAT THEY DEAL WITH. I MEAN, THEY'VE GOT VERY SPECIFIC CODE PROVISIONS AND STUFF LIKE THAT. OKAY. WELL, YOU KNOW, AS LONG AS IT'S NOT IT DOESN'T CONSTITUTE A STRUCTURE UNDER THE CODE. I DON'T HAVE A PROBLEM WITH IT STAYING OUT THERE. SO BUT. ANYTHING ELSE AT THIS POINT, YOU CAN SEE I HAVE TWO WASTE [00:40:03] MANAGEMENT DUMPSTERS AROUND THERE AND I'M KEEPING THEM FULL WELL. YOU'VE GOT A FEW MORE ITEMS TO PUT IN THERE, BUT LET'S LET'S SEE IF WE CAN GET THEM GONE. ANYTHING ELSE? NO, I KNOW, THAT'S IT. I'LL JUST, YOU KNOW, LIKE TO KNOW WHAT'S GOING TO BE GOING ON WITH HER TRAILER. LIKE I SAID, I JUST DON'T WANT MY MOM TO BE RESPONSIBLE. I UNDERSTAND THAT, AND, YOU KNOW, OKAY. BUT I WAS INFORMED THAT SHE'S IN THE PROCESS OF MOVING. BUT I'D HATE TO THINK THAT SHE'S GOING TO LEAVE THAT TRAILER THERE FOR SOMEBODY ELSE TO TAKE CARE OF. WELL, THAT'S UNFORTUNATELY, THAT'S THE REASON YOU'VE GOT TO HAVE VERY WITH WITH MOBILE HOMES, PEOPLE WALK OFF AND LEAVE THEM ALL THE TIME. THAT'S AN UNFORTUNATE REALITY IN LIFE. BUT YOU NEED, YOU KNOW, OF COURSE YOU CAN'T GET BLOOD OUT OF A TURNIP, BUT I MEAN. THE THE LEASE AGREEMENT FOR A GROUND LEASE FOR A MOBILE HOME, IT REALLY NEEDS TO BE TIGHT. SO TO MAKE SURE THAT THEY DON'T LEAVE YOU HOLDING THE BAG, SO TO SPEAK, WAS THE LEASE AGREEMENT OR NOTHING? SHE WAS JUST ALLOWED TO PUT IT THERE AND LIVE. AND THAT'S, YOU KNOW. NO GOOD DEED GOES UNPUNISHED. I GUESS OVER 30 YEARS AGO. RIGHT. OKAY. ALL RIGHT. WELL, JUST SO HAPPENED IF IF MY MOM HAS SOLE RESPONSIBILITY FOR HER TRAILER BEING TORE DOWN, I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW, BECAUSE I COULD SEE REMOVING IT. BUT I'M GOING TO HAVE TO GET PERMISSION TO TEAR DOWN SOMEBODY ELSE'S TRAILER. RIGHT? WELL, YOU KNOW, I'M NOT INCLINED TO HOLD YOUR MOTHER RESPONSIBLE FOR IT. I'LL PUT IT THAT WAY. OKAY. BASED ON THE TESTIMONY I'VE HEARD AND THE EXHIBITS THAT I'VE SEEN IN THE FORM OF PHOTOGRAPHS INTRODUCED INTO EVIDENCE, I'M GOING TO FIND THAT THE LOCATE THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 6114 EAST SIXTH STREET, IS WITHIN THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF BAY COUNTY AND THEREFORE SUBJECT TO THE PROVISIONS OF CHAPTER 17 OF THE CODE, NOTICE HAS BEEN GIVEN TO THE RESPONDENT. THEY HAVE APPEARED AND TESTIFIED IN CONNECTION WITH THIS MATTER AND BEEN AFFORDED TO INTRODUCE AN EXHIBIT WHICH HAS BEEN MADE A PART OF THE FILE. THE. PROPERTY DOES HAVE A VIOLATION OF 1702, IN THE FORM OF AN UNFIT OR UNSAFE MOBILE HOME ON THE PREMISES, AS WELL AS AN UNFIT OR UNSAFE ACCESSORY STRUCTURE. THERE ARE ALSO VEHICLES, JUNK AND TRASH ON THE PROPERTY. THE. RESPONDENT HAS OBTAINED A DEMOLITION PERMIT FOR THE. ACCESSORY STRUCTURE ON THE PROPERTY, AND HAS REMOVED ONE. MOBILE HOME THAT WAS PREVIOUSLY DECLARED TO BE UNFIT AND UNSAFE. THE BUILDING PERMIT OR EXCUSE NOT THE BUILDING PERMIT, BUT THE DEMOLITION PERMIT. WILL. SEE THERE'S A DATE IN HERE SOMEWHERE. MARCH I THINK 20 OF 26. YEAH. WILL EXPIRE SOMETIME IN MARCH OF 26. SO THE THE RESPONDENT HAS UNTIL THAT TIME TO. TAKE DOWN THE ACCESSORY STRUCTURE. THE. UNFIT OR UNSAFE MOBILE HOME IDENTIFIED AS A BUILDING A OR STRUCTURE A ON THE PREMISES. EXCUSE ME. IS UNFIT OR UNSAFE AND IT CAN BE. THAT VIOLATION CAN BE REMEDIED BY. REPAIRING THE UNFIT OR UNSAFE MOBILE HOME IN THE FOLLOWING MANNER. WELL, I'M NOT EVEN GOING TO GO THROUGH THAT BECAUSE YOU'RE NOT THE OWNER TO THAT THING. IN THE ALTERNATIVE, THAT UNFIT OR UNSAFE MOBILE HOME WILL BE THE SUBJECT OF DEMOLITION. YOU ALSO MUST REMOVE ANY AND ALL JUNK, TRASH, DERELICT VEHICLES OR REMOVE ALL BUT ONE DERELICT VEHICLE FROM THE PREMISES. THE. SINCE YOU [00:45:16] ARE NOT THE OWNER OF THE. MOBILE HOME A I DON'T THINK YOU WILL BE ABLE TO OBTAIN ANY PERMITS IN ORDER TO DEMOLISH IT, BUT MISS BRANNON HAS A PERIOD OF 30 DAYS DURING WHICH SHE MUST REMOVE THE THING OR OR MAKE REPAIRS TO IT. THE REPAIRS WOULD INCLUDE SUBMITTING A COMPLETE BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION TO THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT, AND THAT APPLICATION MUST INCLUDE THE MOBILE HOME MANUFACTURER'S SPECIFICATIONS FOR THAT SPECIFIC MODEL OF MOBILE HOME. OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE ENGINEERING PLANS OR BLUEPRINTS TO SHOW THAT IT IS A DEVIATION FROM THE ORIGINAL HOME TO THE CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION. REMODELING OR REPAIRING MOBILE HOMES REQUIRE THAT YOU USE EXCUSE ME MATERIAL AND DESIGN EQUIVALENT TO THE ORIGINAL CONSTRUCTION. THE STRUCTURE TO BE INCLUDED WITHIN THE SCOPE OF THIS REQUIREMENT INCLUDES, BUT IS NOT LIMITED TO THE ROOF SYSTEM, WALL SYSTEM, FLOOR SYSTEM, WINDOWS AND EXTERIOR DOORS OF THE MOBILE OR MANUFACTURED HOME. ELECTRICAL AND PLUMBING. REPAIR OR REPLACEMENT MUST BE DONE USING MATERIALS AND DESIGN EQUIVALENT TO THE ORIGINAL CONSTRUCTION. THOSE REPAIRS ALSO MUST BE MADE BY A PERSON DESIGNATED AND DEFINED IN SECTION THREE. 20.82454 OF THE FLORIDA STATUTES. IT REQUIRES A SUBMISSION OF A DETAILED ACTION PLAN TO INCLUDING TO INCLUDE TIME FRAMES OUTLINING THE NECESSARY REPAIRS FOR THE STRUCTURE, AND THAT'S GOT TO BE GIVEN TO CODE ENFORCEMENT. ALL REQUIRED PERMITS AND MANUFACTURERS. SPECIFICATION, ENGINEERING PLANS, ETC. HAVE GOT TO GO THROUGH THE PLAN REVIEW PROCESS BEFORE ANY PERMITS WILL ISSUE. THE PERMIT INSPECTIONS HAVE GOT TO BE COMPLETED BY THE BAY COUNTY BUILDERS SERVICES DIVISION STAFF OR DESIGNEE, AND THE REPAIRS MUST BE MADE IN ACCORD WITH THE ACTION PLAN AND STRUCTURAL REPORT. ALL BUILDING PERMIT INSPECTIONS HAVE GOT TO BE COMPLETED AND PERMITS FINALIZED IN ORDER FOR THE REPAIRS TO BE CONSIDERED COMPLETE. IF AT ANY TIME ANY OF THE PERMITS REQUIRED UNDER THIS ORDER SHALL EXPIRE OR BECOME VOID FOR ANY REASON THAT SHALL BE DEEMED A FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH THE TERMS OF THIS ORDER. IT'S THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE RESPONDENT TO CONTACT AND KEEP CODE ENFORCEMENT INFORMED OF THE PROGRESS OR DELAYS IN BRINGING THE PROPERTY INTO COMPLIANCE. IF THE RESPONDENT FAILS TO COMPLY. AND AGAIN, I'M GOING TO I'M GOING TO WAIVE THE FINE BECAUSE YOU'VE BEEN MAKING PROGRESS ON IT. ON GETTING THE PLACE CLEANED UP. NONCOMPLIANCE WILL BE DEEMED TO HAVE OCCURRED IF YOU GET A DEMO OR A BUILDING PERMIT WITHIN THE TIME FRAME, AND THEN YOU ALLOW THE PERMIT TO EXPIRE, OR IT BECOMES VOID FOR ANY REASON THAT WILL BE DEEMED A DEFAULT. AND CONSIDERED A FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH THE TERMS OF THIS ORDER. ANY COST ASSOCIATED FOR ABATING THE VIOLATIONS WILL BECOME. AS IT RELATES TO THE. ACCESSORY STRUCTURE WILL BECOME A LIEN ON THE REAL OR PERSONAL PROPERTY OWNED BY THE RESPONDENT. THE MAGISTRATE WILL ADDRESS THE ISSUE OF COST INCURRED IN ABATING THE VIOLATION. AS TO MOBILE HOME A AT THE COMPLIANCE HEARING, WHICH SHALL BE HELD ON NOVEMBER THE 19TH AT 1 P.M. SO WE'RE GOING TO BE BACK HERE ON THE 19TH TO SEE IF SHE'S FIXED THAT MOBILE HOME. AND AND YOU'VE, YOU KNOW, YOU TECHNICALLY HAVE UNTIL THE 26TH OF MARCH OR WHATEVER IN MARCH TO GET YOUR ACCESSORY STRUCTURE DOWN. SO YOU NEED TO KEEP MAKING PROGRESS ON THAT. AND WE WILL ADDRESS ANY COMPLIANCE OR NONCOMPLIANCE. WHEN'S THE FIRST HEARING THAT WE HAVE AFTER THE EXPIRATION OF THE OR AFTER THE END OF MARCH IN 26? ALL RIGHT. I DON'T HAVE THAT SCHEDULE WITH ME. OKAY. WELL, I'LL JUST I'LL JUST PUT IT THIS WAY. THEN WE [00:50:06] WILL HAVE A COMPLIANCE HEARING AS IT RELATES TO THE ACCESSORY STRUCTURE AT OUR FIRST HEARING DATE AFTER IT EXPIRES IN MARCH OF 26. UNLESS THEY GET DOWN BEFORE. YEAH YEAH YEAH YEAH, YEAH. IF YOU HAVE IT DOWN BY THE 19TH OF NOVEMBER, THEN WE CAN TAKE YOU OFF THE HOOK FOR ANY OTHER HEARINGS AS IT RELATES TO I HAVE ALL THIS CLEANED UP WAY BEFORE THEN OTHER THAN THE TRAILER, I'M SURE IT'S GOING TO BE ABANDONED BECAUSE, LIKE I SAID, I HEARD SHE WAS IN THE PROCESS OF MOVING OUT. THAT'S MY BIGGEST CONCERN, WHAT WE'RE GOING TO DO WITH THE TRAILER, I'M SURE IT'S GOING TO BE TORN DOWN. YEAH. YOU KNOW, DO Y'ALL SEE HER ON A REGULAR BASIS? I DON'T LIVE THERE. MY MOTHER LIVES THERE AND SHE SEES HER, I THINK OCCASIONALLY. DOES SHE SAY ANYTHING TO YOU ALL ABOUT IT? OKAY, WELL, IT GETS A CONFRONTATION AND WE PREFER NOT TO GET I UNDERSTAND THAT, I UNDERSTAND THAT, YEAH, SHE KNOWS SHE'S GOT TO MOVE, I KNOW THAT. OKAY, WELL, SHE'LL. AND I'M SURE AWARE OF IT AS WE GET CLOSER TO THE DAY. AND I'M PRETTY SURE SHE'S GOING TO JUST ABANDON IT AND LEAVE IT THERE AND PROBABLY NOT TAKE ANY RESPONSIBILITY FOR MOVING IT. WELL, SOMETIMES THAT'S THE PRICE YOU GOT TO PAY FOR GETTING RID OF THE PROBLEM. YEAH. OKAY. OKAY. ANYTHING ELSE, MISS ASHBURN? NO. OKAY, SO WE HAVE TO BE BACK ON THE 19TH OF NOVEMBER. I'M GOING TO SAY YES BECAUSE I DON'T KNOW WHERE YOU ARE IN THE OR WILL BE AT THE TIME. I THINK IT WOULD BE SMART IF YOU DID COME ON THE 19TH AT 1:00 AND WE'LL BE BACK IN THIS ROOM, OKAY? OKAY. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT. THAT BRINGS US TO ITEM G. PROPERTY ADDRESS IS 1229 CARUSO DRIVE. FIVE. NUMBER TWO IS JUST AN AERIAL VIEW FOR LOCATION PURPOSES TAKEN EARLIER THIS YEAR. THIS IS AN UNINCORPORATED AREA OF STATE COUNTY COMMONLY KNOWN AS SANDY CREEK. THIS IS. 2297. THANK YOU. SANDY CREEK COMMUNITY HERE. GULF OLD GOLF COURSE, I BELIEVE. AND THAT'S THE PROPERTY IN THE BLUE. CLOSER UP. AERIAL VIEW OF THE PROPERTY. IT IS A VACANT LOT ZONED RESIDENTIAL. AND WE DID RECEIVE ON FEBRUARY 18TH OF THIS YEAR A COMPLAINTS FOR TREE DEBRIS JUNK AND TRASH. INITIALLY, INVESTIGATOR ROBBIE CLARKSON AND INSPECTED THE PROPERTY AND HE DID FIND IT IN VIOLATION OF 17 TWO IN THE FORM OF JUNK TRASH, DEBRIS AND UNSCREENED, UNUSED PERSONAL PROPERTY. AN INFORMAL LETTER WAS SENT AT THAT TIME. SOME OF THE PHOTOS FROM THAT FEBRUARY 18TH, STARTING WITH SLIDE NUMBER FIVE TAKEN FROM THE ROADWAY, YOU SEE VEHICLES. LOOKS LIKE THERE ARE GOING TO BE TRYING TO BUILD A FENCE OR A WALL. THERE. IS THAT VEHICLE SITTING ON SOMETHING OR I THINK IT'S ON A TRAILER. OH, I SEE IT ABOVE THAT WALL. AND I WONDERED HOW THEY GOT UP IN THERE LIKE THAT DEBRIS, SOME TRASH, OLD TENTS. BOX. THERE WAS A LAND DISTURBANCE PERMIT ISSUED FOR THIS PROPERTY. A WHAT? IT'S A LAND CLEARING PERMIT CLEARING. OKAY, OKAY. AND INVESTIGATOR CHRIS HUBBARD WAS REASSIGNED. THIS CASE. I'M GOING TO LET HIM FINISH WITH THE SLIDE SHOW. AS HE'S MOST FAMILIAR WITH CHRIS HUBBARD. BAY COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT, MARCH 17TH. THE PROPERTY WAS REINSPECTED. AS YOU CAN SEE, THAT FRONT FENCE IS NOW DOWN AND YOU CAN SEE THE THE JUNK AND TRASH THE VEHICLE. STOLEN PROPERTY. THERE'S A LITTLE SMALL SHED BACK THERE, THE BIG PILE OF DEBRIS TO THE RIGHT OF THE PHOTOGRAPH THERE. JUST KIND OF A CLOSER SHOT SHOWING THE BACK OF THE PROPERTY WITH THE TRAILER OF THE TRUCK AND THE STUFF SCATTERED AROUND. THIS IS TO THE RIGHT SIDE OF THE PROPERTY. IT LOOKS LIKE SOME BUSTED UP CONCRETE CONSTRUCTION DEBRIS BACK TO THE BACK, AND THE BIG PILE OF DEBRIS PILED UP IN FRONT OF THE PROPERTY THERE. APRIL 7TH, AS WE INSPECTED, REMAINED PRETTY MUCH THE SAME. IT'S KIND OF HARD TO TELL WHEN SOMETHING CHANGES ON AT THIS POINT, BUT IT'S MORE STUFF STORED ON THE PROPERTY. SOME OF IT'S BEEN MOVED AROUND, MAYBE, AND THERE'S A SMALL SHED STILL ON THE PROPERTY. THE BIG DEBRIS PILE REMAINS TO THE RIGHT SIDE OF THE PROPERTY. WE JUST ANOTHER SHOT SHOWING HOW LARGE THE PILE OF DEBRIS THE TREE DEBRIS IS AND THE CONSTRUCTION DEBRIS IN THE BACK. JUNE 5TH PROPERTY WAS INSPECTED. IT'S SHOT FROM CARUSO FROM THE FRONT OF THE PROPERTY, SHOWING THE [00:55:06] LEFT SIDE OF THE PROPERTY CLOSE UP SHOT SHOWING STUFF THE JUNK, TRASH, UNSCREENED, UNUSED STUFF, PERSONAL PROPERTY. IT'S LIKE A CARGO TRAILER HAD BEEN ADDED. THE TRACTOR. YOU STILL SEE THE DEBRIS PILE TO THE FRONT. JUST ANOTHER SHOT OF IT FROM THE ROAD SHOWING HOW LARGE THE PILE IS. SOME STUFF UP TOWARD THE FRONT, SOME BUILT CONSTRUCTION MATERIALS. IT LOOKS LIKE SOME TRASH OR JUNK. JUNE 6TH THE NOTICE WAS SENT OUT. NOTICE OF VIOLATION WAS SENT OUT TO THE PROPERTY OWNER USING THE ADDRESS CONTAINED IN THE PROPERTY APPRAISER'S DATABASE. BOTH THE REGULAR AND THE CERTIFIED MAIL WAS RETURNED WITHOUT SERVICE AUGUST 15TH. THE PROPERTY WAS REINSPECTED AGAIN. FROM THE FRONT YOU CAN SEE STUFF STILL STORED ON THE PROPERTY THE JUNK, TRASH, CONSTRUCTION MATERIALS, THE VEHICLES, THE STRUCTURE AND THE DEBRIS PILE REMAINS. A LOT OF STUFF AT THE FRONT STILL REMAINS. THE DRUMS AND CONSTRUCTION MATERIALS AND THE ENORMOUS PILE STARTING TO OVERGROW, SO IT'S GETTING A LITTLE HARD TO SEE. IT LOOKS LIKE ANOTHER SHED HAS BEEN CONSTRUCTED THERE TO THE RIGHT. THE PROPERTY IN FRONT OF THAT, IT WAS CARGO TRAILER THERE AND SOME MORE DEBRIS SCATTERED AROUND SEPTEMBER 4TH, WE INSPECTED THE PROPERTY. IT REMAINED IN VIOLATION. YOU SEE, WE'VE ADDED ANOTHER VEHICLE ON THE TRAILER. I THINK THAT EXPLAINS THE FIRST PICTURE OVER THE FENCE. AND OF COURSE, THE OVERGROWTH IS MAKING IT HARD TO SEE ALL THE STUFF, BUT IT STILL REMAINS THE SAME AS IN THE EARLIER PICTURES. THE STUFF UP BY THE FRONT OF THE FENCE, BOTH THE VEHICLE STORED ON THE PROPERTY, AND AT THIS POINT, I BELIEVE THERE'S TWO SHEDS ON THE PROPERTY. THAT ONE IN THE PREVIOUS ONE AT THE START OF THE CASE AND THE CARGO TRAILER, AND THERE YOU GO. AND THE CONSTRUCTION DEBRIS. SEPTEMBER 5TH, THE NOTICE OF VIOLATION NOTICE OF HEARING WAS SENT, CERTIFIED, MAILED TO THE PROPERTY OWNER'S ADDRESS OBTAINED FROM THE PROPERTY APPRAISER'S SITE. BOTH NOTICES RETURNED WITHOUT SERVICE. BOTH REGULAR INDIA CERTIFIED WAS RETURNED WITHOUT SERVICE SEPTEMBER 24TH. POSTED THE PROPERTY ON THE GATE THERE. AS YOU CAN SEE, THE VIOLATIONS REMAIN PRETTY MUCH UNCHANGED. JUST KIND OF MOVED AROUND A LITTLE BIT IN THE BACKGROUND. OCTOBER 1ST, THE FINAL INSPECTION FOR THIS HEARING, AND YOU CAN SEE THE PROPERTY REMAINS IN VIOLATION. THE NOTICE IS STILL THERE ON THE GATE AND IT REMAINS PRETTY MUCH AS IT WAS. IT WAS NOTED ON OCTOBER 1ST. I CHECKED THE PERMITS AND THERE WAS A LAND DISTURBANCE OR LAND CLEARING PERMIT WAS ISSUED BACK IN MAY 1ST OF 2024. THAT PERMIT DIDN'T GIVE THEM PERMISSION TO CLEAR THE LAND, BUT IT ALSO NOTED ON THERE THAT ANY ADDITIONAL PERMIT, THAT ADDITIONAL PERMITS WOULD BE REQUIRED IF ANY STRUCTURES WERE BUILT, SHEDS OR MOVED ONTO THE PROPERTY. THERE WAS A PHONE NUMBER ON THAT PERMIT FROM 2024 SO CALLED IT LEFT A VOICEMAIL FOR IT, AND THE PROPERTY OWNER CALLED ME BACK AND SPOKE WITH HER. SHE HAD NOT RECEIVED ANOTHER VIOLATION. SHE SAID SHE HAD CHANGED HER ADDRESS, BUT THE PROPERTY APPRAISER HAD NOT BEEN UPDATED. SO WE DISCUSSED THE CASE AND SHE'S HERE TODAY TO SPEAK ON HER BEHALF. THE CASE IS SCHEDULED FOR COMPLIANCE HEARING ON NOVEMBER 19TH, AND THAT'S ALL I HAVE FOR NOW. COME ON UP AND TELL US. GIVE US YOUR NAME AND GIVE US A GOOD MAILING ADDRESS. MY NAME IS JESSICA MARTINEZ. AND MY MAILING, MY MAILING ADDRESS IS 604 CYPRESS AVENUE, 604 CYPRESS. OKAY. ALL RIGHT. WHAT DO YOU WANT US TO KNOW, MA'AM? WELL, I WASN'T AWARE OF ANYTHING THAT WAS HERE. AND I RECEIVED A CALL FROM HIM, AND HE EXPLAINED ME WHAT WAS GOING ON. SO THAT'S WHY I'M HERE. WHOSE VEHICLES ARE THOSE? WELL, IT WAS. I THINK MY HUSBAND HELPED THIS FRIEND BECAUSE IT WAS BROKE DOWN, SO. BUT IT'S GONE ALREADY. SO. YEAH. AND THEY JUST PUT IT THERE FOR A LITTLE BIT SO THEY CAN GET IT OFF. BUT THEY'VE HAD VEHICLES THERE FOR A NUMBER OF NUMBER OF THE PHOTOGRAPHS TAKEN OVER A PERIOD OF TIME. SO. OH THE WHITE ONE. THE WHITE TRUCK. YEAH. THAT'S MY HUSBAND. THEY'VE BEEN VEHICLES ON THE PROPERTY FOR QUITE SOME TIME. WHAT ABOUT THIS CONSTRUCTION DEBRIS THAT'S OUT THERE? WELL, I GUESS MY HUSBAND WAS DOING SOMETHING AND HE JUST WENT AND PUT IT THERE, SO. YEAH. WELL. IT CAN'T BE A DISPOSAL SITE. YES, I KNOW THAT'S THE BOTTOM LINE. YES. SO. [01:00:18] OKAY. HAVE YOU HAVE YOU TALKED WITH YOU AND YOUR HUSBAND DISCUSSED THE MATTER OF CLEANING THIS, ALL THIS STUFF UP? YES WE DID. HE ALREADY GOT A FRIEND, BUT HE SAID HE WAS AVAILABLE, LIKE IN TWO WEEKS TO GO AND GET THE DAMN TRAILER AND TO GET IT OFF THE PROPERTY. WELL, THAT THAT PILE OF STUFF. I DON'T KNOW IF THAT'S GOING. I MEAN, THAT'S A PRETTY BIG PILE, IS WHAT I'M SAYING. IT WAS BIGGER. WE ALREADY GOT SOME OF IT DOWN. I MEAN, YEAH, OKAY. ANYTHING ELSE YOU WANT TO ADD? WELL, NO, I JUST NEEDED A LITTLE MORE TIME TO CLEAN IT UP AND GET OTHER STUFF. OKAY. NOW THE THE GATE HAS A AN ORNAMENTAL SIGN ON IT WITH VAQUERO ON IT. YEAH. THAT'S. HER HUSBAND IS VAQUERO. THAT'S MY HUSBAND. LAST NAME MY KIDS. ALL RIGHT. YEAH. THAT'S NOT MY LAST NAME. IT HAS A PROPERTY. IN YOUR NAME OR HIS NAME? IT'S MY NAME. OKAY. ALL RIGHT. ANYTHING ELSE? OKAY. ALL RIGHT. BASED ON THE TESTIMONY THAT I'VE HEARD AND THE PHOTOGRAPHS THAT I'VE SEEN INTRODUCED INTO EVIDENCE, I'M GOING TO FIND THAT THE THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT ONE, TWO, 229 CARUSO DRIVE, IS IN THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF BAY COUNTY AND SUBJECT TO THE PROVISIONS OF CHAPTER 17 OF THE CODE, IN CHAPTER FOUR OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS, THAT NOTICE WAS GIVEN TO THE RESPONDENT BY POSTING. ALSO, SHE HAS CONTACTED CODE ENFORCEMENT AFTER HAVING RECEIVED A VOICEMAIL AND HAS APPEARED AT THIS HEARING AND TESTIFIED AND BEEN AFFORDED THE OPPORTUNITY TO OFFER ANY EVIDENCE THAT SHE WANTS TO. THERE IS A VIOLATION OF 1702 ON THE PREMISES IN THE FORM OF JUNK, TRASH, TREE AND YARD DEBRIS, CONSTRUCTION DEBRIS, AND THERE IS A VIOLATION OF CHAPTER FOUR OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS IN THE FORM OF STORAGE ON A VACANT RESIDENTIAL LOT. I'M GOING TO GIVE HER 20 DAYS INSTEAD OF TEN, BECAUSE THERE'S A LOT OF STUFF TO CLEAN UP HERE. WE'LL GIVE YOU 20 DAYS TO BRING THE PROPERTY INTO COMPLIANCE BY REMOVING AND LAWFULLY DISPOSING OF ALL JUNK, TRASH, TREE AND YARD DEBRIS AND CONSTRUCTION DEBRIS. ALL TRAILERS, VEHICLES, UNPERMITTED SHEDS, AND PERSONAL PROPERTY MUST ALSO BE REMOVED. SO THEY SAID YOU DIDN'T HAVE ANY PERMITS FOR THOSE SHEDS. THEY GOT TO GET GONE. THE. KEY WORD, I GUESS YOU'D SAY, IN THAT THING, LAWFULLY DISPOSING OF ALL OF IT. SO YOU CAN'T JUST, YOU KNOW, SCOOP IT UP AND GO PUT IT ON SOMEBODY ELSE'S PROPERTY. IT'S GOT TO BE PROPERLY DISPOSED OF. THE RESPONDENT SHALL HAVE THE RESPONSIBILITY TO CONTACT AND INFORM CODE ENFORCEMENT OF ANY PROGRESS OR DELAYS IN BRINGING THE PROPERTY INTO COMPLIANCE. IF THE RESPONDENT FAILS TO BRING THE PROPERTY INTO COMPLIANCE WITH THE APPLICABLE CODES, ORDINANCES AND REGULATIONS WITHIN 20 DAYS OF THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF THE ORDER, THE RESPONDENT WILL BE FINED AN INITIAL FINE OF $200 AND A DAILY FINE OF $25 A DAY, TO BE IMPOSED AFTER THE 20TH DAY, FOR A PERIOD OF 20 DAYS, OR UNTIL THE PROPERTY IS BROUGHT INTO COMPLIANCE, WHICHEVER SHALL OCCUR FIRST IS THE RESPONDENT'S RESPONSIBILITY TO NOTIFY CODE ENFORCEMENT THAT THE PROPERTY HAS BEEN BROUGHT INTO COMPLIANCE SO AN INSPECTION CAN BE CONDUCTED IN ORDER TO STOP THE FINE. THE FINE WILL BECOME A LIEN ON THE RESPONDENT'S PROPERTY, BOTH REAL AND PERSONAL. LOCATED HERE IN BAY COUNTY. OKAY, I'M GIVING YOU 20 DAYS TO GET IT ALL CLEANED UP AND EVERYTHING. BUT IF YOU GET, [01:05:06] SAY YOU GET IT CLEANED UP IN TEN DAYS, YOU CALL CODE ENFORCEMENT AND SAY, LOOK, I'VE GOT IT CLEANED UP, PLEASE COME AND TAKE A LOOK AT IT. SO THE FINES DON'T RUN ON ME OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT, OR, YOU KNOW, IF IF YOU GOT IT CLEANED UP IN 30 DAYS, WHERE THE FINES HAVE BEEN RUNNING FOR FOR TEN OF THE 20 DAYS, AGAIN, CALL CODE ENFORCEMENT SO THEY CAN COME OUT AND LOOK AT IT. THEY'VE GOT TO SAY IT'S IN COMPLIANCE. OR IF THEY COME OUT THERE AND THEY SAY, HEY, YOU'VE STILL GOT X, Y AND Z ON THE PROPERTY, YOU'RE GOING TO HAVE TO GET IT ALL CLEANED UP. OKAY. ALL RIGHT. DO WE HAVE COMPLIANCE HEARINGS ON THESE? YES. NOVEMBER THE 19TH. RIGHT. I'M JUST MAKING SURE THAT'S 40 DAYS TO MAKE SURE THAT. SO IN OUR TIME FRAME. UPON HEARING OKAY. SO. WELL, IF 20TH DAY WOULD BE THE 20TH OR 20. OKAY, I THINK WE'D BE OKAY. OKAY. ALL RIGHT. WE'LL HAVE A COMPLIANCE HEARING ON NOVEMBER THE 19TH AT 1:00 IN THIS ROOM. OKAY. SO, YOU KNOW, WE'LL THEY'LL COME BACK AND REPORT TO ME WHETHER OR NOT YOU'VE GOT EVERYTHING CLEANED UP. OKAY? OKAY. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU, THANK YOU. OKAY. H I BELIEVE IS NEXT. J H H NO. YOU'RE RIGHT. YEAH. H. HENRY. OKAY. AND THIS IS A FINAL HEARING. PROPERTY ADDRESS IS 3521 EAST ORLANDO ROAD. A COMPLIANCE HEARING WAS HELD BY THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FOR BAY COUNTY ON JUNE 18TH, 2025. THE MAGISTRATE FOUND THAT THE RESPONDENT FAILED TO COMPLY WITH THE FIRST HEARING ORDER HELD ON MAY 14TH, 2025. RESPONDENT DID APPEAR AT THE HEARING. PHOTOS OF THE PROPERTY ARE INTRODUCED INTO EVIDENCE, EXHIBIT A AND ARE CONTAINED IN THE CASE FILE. THESE FIRST PHOTOS ARE. SLIDE NUMBER THREE WERE PRESENTED TO YOU AT THE TIME OF THAT HEARING TO REMIND YOU OF. THESE WERE NOT. THESE ARE TAKEN ON JUNE 26TH. JUST TO REMIND YOU THE CONDITION OF THE PROPERTY, THE MAGISTRATE DIRECTED STAFF TO ABATE THE NUISANCE AND ALL INCIDENTAL COSTS OF ENFORCEMENT TO CONSTITUTE A LIEN AGAINST THE REAL PROPERTY IN WHICH THE VIOLATION EXISTED, AND UPON ANY OTHER REAL OR PERSONAL PROPERTY OWNED BY THE RESPONDENT. A COPY OF THIS ORDER IS INTRODUCED INTO EVIDENCE AS EXHIBIT B, AND IS CONTAINED IN THE CASE FILE. ON JUNE 10TH, 2025, AN ASBESTOS SURVEY WAS COMPLETED AT THE COST OF $800. ON JULY 16TH, 2025, A NOTICE OF INTENT WAS SENT, CERTIFIED AND REGULAR MAIL TO THE PROPERTY OWNER AND ANY OTHER INTERESTED PARTIES. ON JUNE 26TH, A BRIEF A PRE-BID INSPECTION WAS COMPLETED, WHICH THE PHOTOS THAT YOU JUST SAW. THE PROPERTY WAS CLEANED BY A COMPANY, A CLAIM BY A COMPANY CONTRACTED BY THE COUNTY AT A COST OF $2,850, AND ON AUGUST 11TH, 2025 WAS FOUND TO BE IN COMPLIANCE. AS YOU SEE IN SLIDE NUMBER SIX, ON AUGUST 18TH, CODE ENFORCEMENT RECEIVED A CHECK FOR THE TOTAL AMOUNT OWED FOR THE COST OF ABATEMENT FROM JIMMY AND LINDA RICHARDSON. ON THAT AUGUST 19TH, A FINAL HEARING NOTICE WAS SENT AND WAS DELIVERED TO THE RESPONDENT ON THE 22ND. IT IS OUR RECOMMENDATION THAT THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE DETERMINED THAT THE PROPERTY IS NOW IN COMPLIANCE WITH THE MAGISTRATE'S ORDER, OKAY, BASED ON THE TESTIMONY I'VE HEARD AND THE EXHIBITS. WELL, LET ME ASK YOU, IS SOMEBODY ON BEHALF OF THE PROPERTY HERE WANT TO SPEAK? I'D JUST LIKE TO THANK CODE ENFORCEMENT FOR THEIR ASSISTANCE IN THESE CIRCUMSTANCES TO GET THIS TAKEN CARE OF. WE APPRECIATE YOUR COOPERATION IN THIS MATTER. AND IT SURE LOOKS A LOT BETTER. YES. OKAY. ALL RIGHT. BASED ON THE TESTIMONY I'VE HEARD IN THE EXHIBITS, I'VE SEEN INTRODUCED INTO EVIDENCE, I'M GOING TO FIND THAT THE PROPERTY IS NOW IN COMPLIANCE. IN THIS CASE SHALL BE CLOSED. THANK YOU. THANK YOU FOR COMING. APPRECIATE YOUR COOPERATION. THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT. NOW WE HAVE ITEM J. WHICH PROPERTY [01:10:07] ADDRESS IS 4113 RAINFOREST ROAD. AGAIN THIS CASE WENT BEFORE A SPECIAL MAGISTRATE OF BAY COUNTY SEPTEMBER 17TH, 2025 AND WAS FOUND IN VIOLATION BAY COUNTY CODE 17 DASH TWO, IN THE FORM OF AN UNFIT AND UNSAFE MOBILE HOME, UNFIT, UNSAFE ACCESSORY STRUCTURE AND JUNK. THE RESPONDENT DID APPEAR AT THE HEARING. PHOTOGRAPHS OF THE PROPERTY ARE INTRODUCED INTO EVIDENCE AS EXHIBIT A AND CONTAINED IN A CASE FILE. THE MAGISTRATE ORDERED THAT THE RESPONDENT HAVE TEN DAYS TO BRING THE PROPERTY INTO COMPLIANCE, OR INITIAL FINE OF $500 WILL BE IMPOSED IF THE PROPERTY IS NOT BROUGHT INTO COMPLIANCE. A COPY OF MAGISTRATE ORDER MAGISTRATE'S ORDER IS INTRODUCED INTO EVIDENCE AS EXHIBIT B ON SEPTEMBER OH. HERE'S MAY 12TH PICTURES THERE. REMEMBER DOUBLE WIDE MOBILE HOME? IT WAS MADE INTO MULTIPLE UNITS. A UNPERMITTED ADDITION AND PORCH WRAPPED AROUND CHICKEN COOP, JUNK, TRASH, ALL KINDS OF GOOD STUFF ON THE PROPERTY. ON SEPTEMBER 24TH, 2025, WE RECEIVED A CALL FROM GEORGE BARBER, WHO ADVISED HE WAS SCHEDULED TO CLOSE ON THE PROPERTY ON SEPTEMBER 26TH, 2025, AND THE LIEN COMPANY SENT HIM THE LIEN SEARCH SHOWING THIS CASE. MISS CROSBY, FROM CODE ENFORCEMENT COORDINATOR EXPLAINED THE VIOLATION. AND WHEN THE THE OCTOBER 22ND, 2025 PRE-BID WOULD BE CONDUCTED AND HOW THE BID WOULD GO TO THE LOWEST BIDDER. SHE ALSO ADVISED THAT THERE WILL BE AN ASBESTOS SURVEY ACCOMPLISHED BEFORE THE BID TOOK PLACE. HE ADVISED THE MOBILE HOME IS SET FOR FORECLOSURE. MISS JODI THEN ADVISED IF THE FORECLOSURE AND THE VIOLATION STILL REMAIN ON THE PROPERTY, IT WILL BE. IT WILL BE ABATED. AT THAT TIME, HE ADVISED THAT THE BANK'S ATTORNEY INFORMED AND ADVISE OR SORRY. HE ADVISED OF THE BANK ATTORNEY'S INFORMATION. MISS JODI ADVISED THAT THEY HAD BEEN SENT DOCUMENTATION, BUT NO ONE HAS REACHED OUT TO CODE ENFORCEMENT AND ADVISED HIM OF THE NEXT STEP. ON SEPTEMBER 25TH, 2025, MISS CROSBY RECEIVED A CALL FROM DARLENE WITH CORNERSTONE TITLE, WHO ADVISED IF THE ATTORNEY FOR THE BANK HAD CALLED US ASKING IF THEY HAD CALLED. SHE WAS ADVISED THAT WE DID NOT RECEIVE A CALL. IT WAS DISCUSSED ABOUT THE UPCOMING HEARING, AND SHE ADVISED THE NEW PROPERTY OWNER PAID SOMEONE TO CLEAN THE PROPERTY AND SHE WAS ADVISED OF THE NEXT INSPECTION DATE. MISS DARLENE ALSO ADVISED THE MOBILE HOME COMPANY SAID THEY WERE GOING TO PICK UP THE MOBILE HOME ON SEPTEMBER 25TH, 2025. THE STATEMENT OF NONCOMPLIANCE AND NOTICE OF HEARING WAS POSTED AT THE BAY COUNTY GOVERNMENT CENTER ON ON THE WEBSITE. ON SEPTEMBER 29TH, 2025, A CALL WAS RECEIVED FROM GEORGE BARBOUR, WHO ADVISED THE CHICKEN COOP AND ALL THE JUNK AND TRASH WERE REMOVED FROM THE PROPERTY AND THAT WEEKEND BY HIM. ON SEPTEMBER 29TH, 2025, INSPECTION WAS COMPLETED. THE PROPERTY WAS BROUGHT INTO COMPLIANCE IN REFERENCE TO THE JUNK AND TRASH I MET MYSELF, MR. BARBOUR AT THE PROPERTY AND WE TALKED ABOUT THEIR INTENTIONS AND FOR THE PROPERTY AND WHAT THE MOBILE HOME COMPANY TOLD THEM. THIS IS THE SEPTEMBER 8TH. LET'S SEE THE REMAINDER OF THE CHICKEN COOP TRASH JUNK ON THE BACK OF THE PROPERTY. THE ADDITION STILL ON THERE AND HERE. HERE IS THE 29TH WHERE I MET THE NEW POTENTIAL OWNERS, AND THEY HAVE CLEANED EVERYTHING UP, REMOVED ALL THE ADDITIONS. CHICKEN COOPS GONE, ALL THE PORCH ON THE BACK IS GONE. TRASH AND JUNK IN THE BACKYARD. ON SEPTEMBER 29TH, MISS SIMS CAME IN TO PAY THE $500 FINE AT THE OFFICE, AND AS OCTOBER 25TH 25, THE PROPERTY OWNERSHIP HAS NOT BEEN TRANSFERRED TO MOBILE HOME STILL SITS THERE. THE NEW OWNERS ARE HERE TO LET YOU KNOW ANY INFORMATION. TELL US YOUR NAME AND GIVE US A GOOD MAILING ADDRESS, PLEASE. GEORGE BABER BABER3 THOUSAND 706 MILLSTONE COURT, LYNN HAVEN, FLORIDA 32444 OKAY. AND I'M KATHERINE SIMS AND SAME ADDRESS. OKAY. WHAT DO YOU WANT US TO KNOW? THE PROPERTY IS GETTING CLEANED UP. I FINALLY HEARD BACK FROM THE MOBILE HOME MORTGAGE COMPANIES ATTORNEY. THEY SAID THAT THEY HAD SPOKE WITH THE MARKETING REP, AND I CALLED HIM. I FORWARDED THE EMAIL THAT THEY [01:15:02] SENT ME TO MISS CROSBY AND MR. SHEPHERD, AND THEY TOLD ME THIS MORNING THAT THEY'LL BE OUT WITHIN TWO WEEKS TO REMOVE THE MOBILE HOME. DO YOU KNOW WHETHER OR NOT THEY'VE INSPECTED THIS MOBILE HOME OR. I WAS TOLD THAT THEY SENT SOMEONE OUT TO VERIFY NO ONE WAS LIVING IN IT. WE TURNED THE POWER OFF THE OTHER DAY. YOU KNOW, ONCE I JUST SAW ALL OF THE MODIFICATIONS EARLIER THAT HAD BEEN DONE. AND I GUESS MY QUESTION IS, CAN THEY PUT IT ON THE ROAD? I MEAN, IS IT GOING TO BE STRUCTURALLY SOUND? YEAH. STRUCTURALLY SOUND. THEY'LL, THEY'LL, THEY'LL SPLIT IT IN HALF AND. OKAY. ALL RIGHT. THEY'LL TAKE IT AWAY. IT'S STILL IT'S STILL STRUCTURALLY SOUND AS THE EXTERIOR ENVELOPE IS WHAT THE PREVIOUS OWNER DID WAS JUST KIND OF GUTTED INSIDE AND CHANGED THE WALL SYSTEMS AND PUT UP NEW WALLS AND ADDITIONS. YEAH. I WAS JUST WONDERING IF THE WALLS WERE GOING TO STAY UP WHILE I TOTED IT DOWN THE ROAD, RIGHT? I MEAN, IF THEY DON'T WOULD BE LIKE THAT. THE HIGHWAY 20 THE OTHER DAY WHERE ONE FLIPPED OVER. OH, YUCK. YEAH, I THINK THIS UNIT IS NEW ENOUGH. IT'S NOT THAT OLD. IT'S NOT THAT OLD. SO IT SHOULD BE. IT SHOULD BE ROADWORTHY. OKAY. ALL RIGHT. HAVE YOU CLOSED ON THE PROPERTY? YES, WE HAVE CLOSED ON THE PROPERTY. THAT'S THE TITLE COMPANY TOLD US. YOU KNOW, THEY WOULD HAVE TO DO IT IN LIEU OF OR CONDITION THEREOF WITH THE FINE, THE $500 FINE. SO WE THE SELLER WAS REALLY SHADY AND WE JUST HAD RATHER JUST PAY THAT SO WE COULD CLOSE AND WE'LL MUSCLE THROUGH THIS OTHER STUFF. MR. BEAVER. RIGHT, RIGHT, RIGHT. THEY CLEANED EVERYTHING. REMEMBER, SHE HAD EXPLAINED THAT SHE HIRED SOMEBODY TO CLEAN. THAT WAS FALSE. NO, THEY DID IT ALL. WE DID IT IN TWO DAYS, 240 YARDS OF TRASH AND DEBRIS. YES, IT WAS QUITE INTERESTING. YEAH, WELL, WE APPRECIATE YOUR EFFORTS IN MAKING THE NEIGHBORHOOD NICER TO LOOK AT. OKAY. I'M GOING TO FIND THAT THE PROPERTY IS PRESENTLY IN COMPLIANCE AS IT RELATES TO THE TRASH AND JUNK AS IT RELATES TO THE UNFIT, UNSAFE HOME. I'M GOING TO EXTEND IT A DETERMINATION AS IT RELATES TO THAT UNTIL NOVEMBER THE 18TH TO REMOVE THE THE UNFIT OR UNSAFE MOBILE HOME. AND WE'LL HAVE ANOTHER HEARING ON NOVEMBER THE 19TH AT 1 P.M. SO SO IF EVERYTHING'S GONE, THAT SHOULD BE CLOSED AND OKAY, THAT'S WHAT WE'RE. YEAH. YEAH. JUST SOMETIMES THESE BANKS I DON'T KNOW WHAT IT IS OR THE FINANCE COMPANIES, THEY JUST SIT ON THEIR HANDS AND THEY DON'T GET MOVING. SO DON'T LET THEM SCREW THINGS UP, SO TO SPEAK. I'M CONSTANTLY CALLING THEM OKAY. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. APPRECIATE YOUR HELP. ON THE 19TH, WE WILL JUST REPORT TO THE MAGISTRATE THAT IT'S BEEN REMOVED. YEAH. WE'RE JUST TRYING TO GET THAT REMOVED SO WE CAN CONTINUE WITH OUR. AND IF YOU, YOU KNOW, IF THEY TELL YOU. ALL RIGHT, IT'S GONE. AND THIS IS, YOU KNOW, NOVEMBER THE 1ST OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT. CALL CODE ENFORCEMENT AND SAY LOOK IT'S GONE. THEY GO UP, CHECK IT OUT. AND THEN Y'ALL DON'T HAVE TO WORRY ABOUT COMING ON THE 19TH, OKAY? OKAY. THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU. WELL THAT GET CLOSED IF THEY GET IT OUT EARLIER. YEAH YEAH OKAY. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU. YES, SIR. THANK YOU. HEY THAT BRINGS US TO ITEM C. PROPERTY ADDRESS IS 2628 LAUREL AVENUE LOT D. AND ON NOVEMBER 7TH, 2024, WE DID RECEIVE A COMPLAINT ON THIS PROPERTY FOR DEREK VEHICLES. BACK TO OUR MAP TO DO THE LOCATION. LOCATED ON THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF PANAMA CITY BEACH, THIS IS THE PROPERTY OUTLINED IN BLUE. THE FOUR LANE. SEVEN. CLOSER UP AERIAL VIEW. SO THIS IS THE. THIS IS THE MOBILE HOME WE'LL BE DISCUSSING LOT NUMBER D CIRCLED IN RED. AND. I BELIEVE YOU HEARD THE OTHER CASES THAT [01:20:04] I'M NOT SURE. THERE WERE SEVERAL VIOLATIONS ON THIS PROPERTY. THIS WAS AN UNFIT UNSAFE STRUCTURES. THIS WAS THE ONLY ONE AT THE TIME THAT ACTUALLY OBTAINED A DEMOLITION PERMIT. SO IT WAS NOT PRESENTED WITH THE OTHER CASES BACK IN NOVEMBER. THIS IS THE PROPERTY FROM NOVEMBER 2024 THAT WILL BE DISCUSSING. AND INSPECTOR THORPE CONDUCTED A BUILDING INSPECTION ON DECEMBER 3RD OF 2024. AND HE IS HERE TO TESTIFY. GOOD MORNING AGAIN, INSPECTOR THORPE. SINGLE WIDE MOBILE HOME THAT SITS IN THIS PARK. THERE WERE FIVE INDIVIDUAL SINGLE WIDES AT THE TIME OF INSPECTION, THREE OF WHICH, WELL, THE FOUR IN THE REAR WERE CONDEMNED. TWO HAVE BEEN REMOVED. ONE'S WAITING. ASBESTOS IS IN THE FRONT LEFT. D DID OBTAIN A DEMOLITION PERMIT IN MARCH 26TH OF 2025, WHICH HAS SINCE EXPIRED. AS OF SEPTEMBER 26TH. BUT IF YOU CAN SEE RIGHT THERE IN SLIDE SEVEN BEHIND THE POWER POLE, THERE'S A NEW PORTION OF THE ROOF THAT WAS PUT ON. IT'S LIKE A PART OF A SHED ROOF THAT WAS LAID OVER THE TOP FOR LIKE A CAROLINA CARPORT. THERE YOU GO. IT WAS JUST ROLLED ON THERE AND LOOKING AT OUR GLOBAL IMAGING SYSTEM, OUR GIS, YOU CAN SEE IN THE CENTER OR INTO THE LEFT PORTION OF PHOTOGRAPH EIGHT, THERE IS A HUGE DENT. THERE WAS A TREE STRIKE TO IT, SO IT DAMAGED SOME OF THE ROOF. AND THAT'S THAT'S WHY THE ROOF OVER WAS PUT ON THERE. AS WE GO AROUND THE BACK, JUST SHOWING THERE'S NO EXISTING ROOF THAT'S UNDER THERE. YOU CAN SEE WHERE THEY TOOK THE TRIM PANEL OFF THERE ON A SHEETING WHERE IT'S NOT PAINTED, LAID THAT GREEN METAL ROOF OVER THE TOP OF IT AND THEN EXPOSED AT THE GABLE END THERE. AND SHEETING IS WEATHER BEATEN AND HAS SEPARATED, EXPOSING THE INTERIOR. AND THE, THE THE FRONT SIDE AND THE SIDES ARE TEN. THE BACK IS T111 WOOD SIDING. SO THERE'S BEEN REPAIRS. SEVERAL AREAS OF THE TEN HAS HAVE SEPARATED. THE UNDERLAYMENT IS IS FALLEN. THERE'S FOUR BY FOURS. INSTEAD OF BLOCKING HOLDING UP THE THE THE WALL SECTION OF THE MOBILE HOME. HOLE IN THE DOOR ALONG WITH ROTTING UNDERNEATH THE DOOR CASING. MORE SEPARATION OF THE TEN ON THE BACK THERE THEY HAD SOME KIND OF A ADDITION ON THE BACK, MAYBE HOT WATER HEATER OR SOMETHING. NOW THE FRONT PORCH, IT LOOKED LIKE IT WAS DAMAGED AT ONE TIME AND THEY REBUILT IT. GO AHEAD. NEXT PHOTO PLEASE. YOU CAN SEE WHERE THEY SPLICED ALL THE THE PORCH LEGS THERE. THERE HAS TO BE FOR THE FLORIDA BUILDING CODE. CONTINUOUS LOAD PATH FROM THE GROUND TO THE ROOF THAT SPLICING WOULD NOT PASS. AND IT'S DONE ON ALL FOUR CORNERS. GREAT ATTEMPT, BUT FAILED ON EXECUTION. OUCH. YEAH, IMPALE YOURSELF ON THOSE. EXACTLY. AS IT SITS. UNFIT, UNSAFE. MOBILE HOME. IT SHOULD BE THE LAST ONE TO BE REMOVED. AND THAT PARK. COUNTY BURNING BAY COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT ON DECEMBER 31ST, 2024. NOTICE OF VIOLATION WAS SENT, CERTIFIED AND REGULAR MAIL TO THE OWNER. RECORD USING THE ADDRESS PO BOX 1931, BLAIRSVILLE, GEORGIA 30514 CERTIFIED NOTICE WAS DELIVERED TO THE RESPONDENT ON JANUARY 14TH OF 2025. THAT NOTICE WAS SENT TO THE ACTUAL PROPERTY OWNER. THE MOBILE HOME IS OWNED BY A DIFFERENT PERSON. NOTICE OF VIOLATION WAS SENT CERTIFIED REGULAR MAIL TO THE MOBILE HOME OWNER USING ADDRESS 2628 LORI AVENUE, LOT D, PANAMA CITY BEACH, FLORIDA 32408. THE CERTIFIED NOTICE WAS DELIVERED ON JANUARY THE 8TH OF 2025. FEBRUARY 24TH, 2025. WE INSPECTED THE PROPERTY. IT REMAINS IN VIOLATION. ON MARCH 4TH, 2025, A NOTICE OF VIOLATION NOTICE OF HEARING WAS SENT CERTIFIED REGULAR MAIL TO THE OWNER RECORD USING ADDRESS PO BOX 1931, BLAIRSVILLE, GEORGIA 30514 CERTIFIED. NOTICE WAS DELIVERED TO THE RESPONDENT ON MARCH 19TH OF 2025. ALSO SENT A NOTICE OF VIOLATION NOTICE OF HEARING. CERTIFIED REGULAR MAIL TO THE MOBILE HOME [01:25:01] OWNER USING THE ADDRESS. 2628 LORI AVENUE, LOT D, PANAMA CITY BEACH, FLORIDA. 32408. THE CERTIFIED NOTICE RETURNED UNCLAIMED. THE REGULAR MAIL DID NOT RETURN. ON MARCH THE 10TH, 2025, I SPOKE WITH PAULA PAULINA LOPEZ, WHO IS THE OWNER OF THE MOBILE HOME AT LOT D. WE DISCUSSED THE VIOLATION CONCERNING HER MOBILE HOME. SHE ADVISED SHE WOULD TRY TO OBTAIN A DEMOLITION PERMIT. ON MARCH 20TH 25 OWNER AND ENCUMBRANCE REPORT WAS RECEIVED. A COPY OF THE NOTICE OF HEARING WAS SENT TO BRITTANY WILLIAMS USING THE ADDRESS. 1631 TOTEM POLE WAY, KRUM, TEXAS. 76 276249. MARCH 26TH, 2025 DEMOLITION PERMIT WAS OBTAINED. THE PERMIT EXPIRES ON SEPTEMBER 26TH OF 2025. DUE TO THE FACT THAT A DEMOLITION PERMIT WAS OBTAINED, THE CASE WAS TAKEN OFF THE AGENDA THAT WAS SCHEDULED FOR APRIL 10TH OF 2025. JULY 21ST, 2025 I REINSPECTED THE PROPERTY AND IT REMAINS IN VIOLATION. NO CHANGE. AUGUST 19TH, 2025 A NOTICE OF VIOLATION NOTICE HEARING WAS SENT, CERTIFIED AND REGULAR MAIL TO THE OWNER OF RECORD USING THE ADDRESS PO BOX 1931, BLAIRSVILLE, GEORGIA 30514. THE CERTIFIED NOTICE WAS DELIVERED TO THE RESPONDENT ON AUGUST THE 30TH, 2025. ALSO SENT A NOTICE OF VIOLATION NOTICE OF HEARING CERTIFIED REGULAR MAIL TO THE MOBILE HOME OWNER USING THE ADDRESS. 2628 LORI AVENUE, LOT D, PANAMA CITY BEACH, FLORIDA. 3248. THE CERTIFIED NOTICE WAS DELIVERED TO THE RESPONDENT ON SEPTEMBER 2ND OF 2025. A COPY OF THE NOTICE OF HEARING WAS ALSO SENT TO BRITTANY WILLIAMS USING ADDRESS 1631, TOTEM POLE WAY, KRUM, TEXAS 76 249. THAT NOTICE WAS RETURNED AUGUST 25TH, 2025. I SPOKE WITH PAULINA LOPEZ AGAIN. I EXPLAINED THE NOTICE OF HEARING, ADVISED HER OF THE HEARING DATE, AND SHE ADVISED SHE WOULD ATTEND THE HEARING AND SHE IS HERE TODAY. ON SEPTEMBER 25TH, 2025, THE PROPERTY WAS POSTED AS WELL AS THE BAY COUNTY GOVERNMENT CENTER. ON OCTOBER THE 6TH, 2025, WE INSPECTED THE PROPERTY. IT REMAINS A VIOLATION IN THIS CASE. IS SCHEDULED FOR COMPLIANCE HEARING ON NOVEMBER 19TH, 2025 AT 1 P.M. WHO GOT THE. DEMOLITION PERMIT BACK IN MARCH OF 25. MISS LOPEZ OKAY, THE MOBILE HOMEOWNER OKAY. ALL RIGHT. MISS LOPEZ, YOU WANT TO COME FORWARD? YES, SIR. YOU'LL NEED TO SWEAR YOU IN. RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND. YOU SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT THE TESTIMONY YOU'RE ABOUT TO GIVE IS THE TRUTH. THE WHOLE TRUTH. AND HERSELF. YES, I DO. TELL US YOUR NAME AND GIVE US A GOOD MAILING ADDRESS. MY NAME IS PAULINA LOPEZ, AND MY ADDRESS IS 1824. 15TH STREET, PANAMA CITY. 32401. OKAY. NOW. THE INITIAL THING IS. A AN LLC. ARE YOU CONNECTED TO THE LLC IN ANY WAY OR DO THEY OWN THE LAND? THEY OWN THE LAND SHE OWNS? OKAY, OKAY. ALL RIGHT. LET ME LET ME SEE IF I CAN SORT OF GO THROUGH THIS THING AND. THE ENCUMBRANCE WAS SENT TO BRITTANY WILLIAMS. IS THAT A, LIKE A MORTGAGE HOLDER? I'M NOT SURE WHO SHE IS. I HAVE NO CONTACT. OKAY. DO YOU KNOW WHO BRITTANY WILLIAMS IS? NO, BECAUSE THE PROPERTY HAS BEEN SELLING, I GUESS, TO DIFFERENT PEOPLE. AND I DON'T KNOW ALL THE NAMES OF THE PEOPLE. ALL RIGHT. IT SHOWED THAT YOU GOT A DEMOLITION PERMIT IN MARCH OF 25. THAT EXPIRED IN SEPTEMBER OF 25. IS THERE A REASON THAT YOU DIDN'T FOLLOW THROUGH WITH THE DEMOLITION? I GOT THE PERMITS BECAUSE THERE IS A GROUP OF COMMISSIONERS FOR CHURCH FROM THE CHURCH. THEY TOLD ME THAT THEY'RE GOING TO HELP ME TO TEAR DOWN ON SUMMER TIME. BUT SINCE THAT TIME, THEY SAID THAT THEY COULDN'T COME AND THEY SEE IT'S TOO HOT. [01:30:05] THEY'RE NOT COMING AT ALL. SO THAT'S WHY I COULD NOT GET IT DEMOLISHED. ALL RIGHT. WHAT DO YOU WANT US TO KNOW AT THIS TIME? WELL, SINCE I HEARD FROM THEM, THEY'RE NOT. THEY'RE NOT COMING. AND THEY EXPIRED THE PERMIT ALREADY, SO I WOULD LIKE TO. I GOT NO CHOICE. LIKE THE CITY CAN DO IT FOR ME. OKAY. TO DEMOLISH. ALLIGHT. ANYTHING ELSE THAT YOU WANT TO ADD OR QUESTIONS THAT YOU HAVE? NO, I JUST WANTED TO TO SEE IF THE CITY IS GOING TO DO IT FOR ME, HOW IT'S GOING TO BE, THE PAYMENT I'M JUST WORRIED ABOUT BECAUSE, YOU KNOW, ABOUT THE MONEY. AND I WANTED TO SEE HOW THAT'S GOING TO BE, HOW MUCH I'M GOING TO PAY OR. IS THERE ANY ESTIMATION. SO THAT CAN BE I DON'T KNOW HOW, IN LIGHT OF THE FACT SHE'S NOT THE OWNER OF THE PROPERTY, YOU OWN THE PROPERTY WHERE YOU LIVE? NO I'M NOT. THAT'S WHY I. I'M CONFUSED, YOU KNOW, I DON'T KNOW WHAT TO DO. AND. AND IN THIS CASE, I, I THINK THE OTHER ONES WENT ON. THE PROPERTY OWNER, SIR. PARDON. I THINK THE OTHER, THE OTHER TWO THAT WE DEMOLISHED, THEY THEY'RE GOING TO GO ON THE PROPERTY OWNER. OKAY. ALL RIGHT. FROM THE COMPANY OUT OF GEORGIA. ALL RIGHT. BASED ON THE TESTIMONY THAT I'VE HEARD AND THE EXHIBITS I'VE SEEN INTRODUCED INTO EVIDENCE, I'M GOING TO FIND THAT THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 2628 LAURY AVENUE, IS IN THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF BAY COUNTY AND SUBJECT TO THE PROVISIONS OF CHAPTER 17 OF THE CODE, NOTICE HAS BEEN GIVEN TO THE RESPONDENT AND THE PROPERTY OWNER HAS NOT APPEARED, BUT THE OWNER OF THE MOBILE HOME HAS APPEARED IN CONNECTION WITH THIS MATTER. THERE IS A VIOLATION OF 17 TWO IN THE FORM OF AN UNFIT OR UNSAFE MOBILE HOME LOCATED ON LOT D OF THIS PROPERTY. THE RESPONDENT AND OR THE. MOBILE HOME OWNER SHALL HAVE A PERIOD OF 30 DAYS TO BRING THE PROPERTY INTO COMPLIANCE BY ADDRESSING THE UNFIT OR UNSAFE MOBILE HOME, THE FOLLOWING MANNER. APPLY FOR AND OBTAIN A DEMOLITION PERMIT TO DEMOLISH THE UNFIT OR MOBILE HOME IN ANY AND ALL PROHIBITED ACCESSORY STRUCTURES IS MADE. THE MAY BE DEFINED IN THE LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS AND REMOVE ALL OF THE DEMOLITION DEBRIS FROM THE PROPERTY OR, IN THE ALTERNATIVE, REPAIR THE UNFIT OR UNSAFE MOBILE HOME IN THE FOLLOWING MANNER. SUBMIT A COMPLETE BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION TO THE BAY COUNTY BUILDING DEPARTMENT AND THAT APPLICATION SHALL INCLUDE THE MOBILE HOME MANUFACTURER'S SPECIFICATIONS FOR THAT SPECIFIC MODEL OF MOBILE HOME OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE ENGINEERING PLANS OR BLUEPRINTS TO SHOW THAT IT IS A DEVIATION FROM THE ORIGINAL HOME TO THE CODE ENFORCEMENT, DIVISION. REPAIR OR REMODELING OF A MOBILE HOME OR MANUFACTURED HOME REQUIRES THE USE OF MATERIAL AND DESIGN EQUIVALENTS TO THE ORIGINAL CONSTRUCTION. THE STRUCTURES WITHIN THE SCOPE OF THIS REQUIREMENT INCLUDE, BUT ARE NOT LIMITED TO, THE ROOF SYSTEM, WALL SYSTEM, FLOOR SYSTEM, WINDOWS, AND EXTERIOR DOORS OF THE MANUFACTURED OR MOBILE OR MOBILE HOME, ELECTRICAL AND PLUMBING REPAIR AND REPLACEMENT REQUIRE THE USE OF MATERIALS AND DESIGN EQUIVALENT TO THE ORIGINAL CONSTRUCTION. REPAIRS HAVE GOT TO BE MADE BY PERSON, DESIGNATED AND DEFINED IN FLORIDA STATUTE SECTION 320 .8245 PERIOD FOR THE RESPONDENT'S GOT TO SUBMIT A DETAILED ACTION PLAN, INCLUDING TIME FRAMES OUTLINING THE NECESSARY REPAIRS FOR THE STRUCTURE TO CODE ENFORCEMENT, ALL REQUIRED PERMITS AND MANUFACTURER SPECIFICATIONS AND ENGINEERING PLANS AND OR BLUEPRINTS HAVE GOT TO GO THROUGH THE PLAN REVIEW PROCESS BEFORE ANY PERMITS WILL ISSUE. ALL PERMIT INSPECTIONS HAVE GOT TO BE COMPLETED BY THE BAY COUNTY BUILDERS SERVICES DIVISION STAFF OR THEIR DESIGNEE, AND THE REPAIRS HAVE GOT TO BE MADE IN ACCORD WITH THE ACTION PLAN AND STRUCTURAL REPORT. ALL BUILDING PERMIT INSPECTIONS HAVE GOT TO BE COMPLETED, AND PERMITS MUST BE FINALIZED IN ORDER FOR THE REPAIRS TO BE CONSIDERED COMPLETE. IF AT ANY TIME THE [01:35:03] REQUIRED PERMITS UNDER THIS ORDER REQUIRE OR EXPIRE OR BECOME VOID FOR ANY REASON, IT SHALL BE DEEMED A FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH THE TERMS OF THIS ORDER. IT'S THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE RESPONDENT AND THE MOBILE HOME OWNER TO CONTACT AND INFORM CODE ENFORCEMENT OF ANY PROGRESS OR DELAYS IN BRINGING THE PROPERTY INTO COMPLIANCE. IF THE RESPONDENT FAILS TO COMPLY WITH THE TERMS OF THIS ORDER WITHIN 30 DAYS FROM THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF THE ORDER, I'M GOING TO REDUCE THE FINE TO $500 WILL BE IMPOSED. THE FINE WILL ALSO BECOME A LIEN ON THE RESPONDENT PROPERTY AS WELL AS A PERSONAL JUDGMENT AS IT RELATES TO THE MOBILE HOME OWNER. THE NONCOMPLIANCE WILL BE DEEMED TO HAVE OCCURRED IF YOU ARE OBTAIN A DEMOLITION OR BUILDING PERMIT WITHIN THE TIME FRAME SET FORTH AND THEN ALLOW IT TO EXPIRE OR BECOME VOID FOR ANY OTHER REASON. AGAIN, THAT SHALL BE DEEMED A DEFAULT AND. FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH THE TERMS OF THIS ORDER. THERE WILL BE A COMPLIANCE HEARING ON NOVEMBER THE 19TH. YES, AT 1:00. ALL RIGHT. WE'LL BE BACK HERE ON NOVEMBER THE 19TH TO SEE IF ANYTHING'S BEEN DONE. AND IF AT THAT POINT IT HASN'T BEEN DONE, THEN THEY'LL MOVE AHEAD TO TAKE IT DOWN. OKAY. AND THEN THAT WILL BECOME A LIEN AGAINST OR A JUDGMENT AGAINST YOU. YEAH. BECAUSE YEAH, THAT'S WHY I WANTED TO BECAUSE THE GUY WHO SAID HE IS THE MANAGEMENT OF THE PROPERTY, HE'S STILL BEEN CHARGING ME FOR THE PROPERTY, FOR THE MOBILE, BEING THERE FOR THE RENT. AND I'VE BEEN PAYING LIKE 200, 100 MONTHLY. SO I WANTED TO, YOU KNOW, AVOID THAT, KEEPING THAT MONEY. THAT'S UP TO YOU WHETHER YOU KEEP PAYING IT OR NOT. SINCE I'M NOT LIVING THERE ANYMORE. AND THEN THE MOBILE HOME. SO I BLAME YOU. SO JUST COME BACK ON THE 19TH. THE 19TH? YES, MA'AM. 1:00. IN ORDER TO CLOSE THE CASE OR IN ORDER TO. TO SEE WHAT THE. MY NAME. RIGHT. OKAY. SO IT WON'T BE IN THE SAME, SAME ROOM. JUST COME BACK ON THE NIGHT. YES, MA'AM. 1:00 IN THE AFTERNOON. OKAY. YEAH. SO TELL ME. SO IT WAS RELEASED ON YOUR OWN. SPIDER, CAN YOU COME KILL IT? IF IT LANDS ON ME, I'M GOING TO SCREAM. OKAY, LITTLE. BUT IT'S UNDER THAT WRAPPER. YEAH. THANK YOU. SO. OKAY. ALL RIGHT, SO I THINK THAT CONCLUDES ALL THE AUDIENCE PARTICIPATION FOR TODAY. SO WE'LL GO BACK TO ITEM B AS IN BOY PROPERTY ADDRESS IS 12213 HAPPY VILLE ROAD. THIS FIRST SLIDE SLIDE NUMBER TWO IS JUST AN AERIAL VIEW OF THE PROPERTY. IT IS LOCATED IN UNINCORPORATED AREA BAY COUNTY, COMMONLY KNOWN AS YOUNGSTOWN. THIS IS PROPERTY THAT WE'LL BE DISCUSSING. IS THAT AREA DOWN TO THE BOTTOM? IS THAT A POND? IT'S NEXT. NEXT PROPERTY BECAUSE WE JUST HEARD THAT SINGLE WIDE MOBILE HOME THERE. THAT'S THOSE SLIMY POND. YEAH, THAT'S A GREEN SLIMY. IT'S NORMALLY FILLED. I'VE BEEN OVER THERE PROPERTY BEFORE DOING A ROOF INSPECTION. BUT IT'S IT'S IT'S OVERGROWN. NOW THIS IS DIRECTLY ACROSS THE STREET. THIS IS THAT PREVIOUS CASE. THE FIRST CASE WE HEARD. THAT'S THE MOBILE HOME. THIS IS DIRECTLY ACROSS THE STREET. AND. INVESTIGATOR SCOTT INITIATED THIS CASE. AND INSPECTOR THORPE IS HERE TO PRESENT. MORNING AGAIN. INSPECTOR THORPE, ON JULY 8TH, 2024, INVESTIGATOR RAYMOND SCOTT OBSERVED THIS PROPERTY WHILE PATROLLING THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF BAY COUNTY KNOWN AS YOUNGSTOWN. INVESTIGATOR SCOTT INSPECTED THE PROPERTY AND FOUND VIOLATION OF BAY COUNTY CODE SECTION 72, IN THE FORM OF UNFIT, UNSAFE STRUCTURE, DERELICT VEHICLES, TRASH AND JUNK PHOTOGRAPHS OF THE PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE AS [01:40:02] EXHIBIT A AND CONTAINED IN THE CASE FILE. TWO CAMPERS BEING OCCUPIED, JUNK AND TRASH THROWN OUT. THEY DON'T HAVE TRASH SERVICE, SO THEY TOSS IT OUT THE BACK THERE. TO SEE WHERE THEY'RE HANGING OUT OUTSIDE. AND THAT'S THE STRUCTURE BEHIND IT, HEAVILY ENCASED IN OVERGROWTH. AND A DEER LICK VEHICLE JUST TO THE NORTH OF THAT. THERE'S A LITTLE BIT BETTER SHOT OF THE ON THE OTHER ROAD, WHERE THE SINGLE WIDE MOBILE HOME WAS OF THE BACK OF THE HOUSE. AND THERE'S THE ROOF. AND SOME MORE JUNK FURNITURE THAT WAS TARPED OVER IN THE DRIVEWAY ON JULY 9TH. THE NOTICE VIOLATION WAS SENT CERTIFIED AND REGULAR MAIL. THE PROPERTY OWNER RECORD. THE CERTIFIED NOTICE WAS RETURNED UNCLAIMED WITH NO FORWARDING ADDRESS. INSPECTIONS WERE CONDUCTED BETWEEN AUGUST 20TH, 2024 AND JANUARY 2025, WITH NO CHANGES TO THE CONDITION OF THE PROPERTY. MARCH 31ST, 2025 AND APRIL 20TH 5TH OR APRIL 2ND, 2020. BUILDING INSPECTIONS CONDUCTED BY MYSELF AND SINGLE FAMILY WOODEN FRAME STRUCTURE THAT SITS ON THE PROPERTY, ALONG WITH TWO ACCESSORY STRUCTURES. THEY WERE NOT. I'M SORRY. OKAY. THEY THEY WERE NOT OCCUPIED AT THE TIME OF INSPECTION. YOU CAN SEE THERE THIS IS FROM THE PREVIOUS TWO DIRT ROADS THAT THEY'RE ON EACH SIDE OF THE, THE THE STRUCTURE. YOU CAN SEE THERE, THE, THE GABLE END ON THE WEST SIDE THERE IS COMPLETELY COLLAPSED IN ROOFS, RIPPED OFF IN THE BACK. OBVIOUSLY THIS IS PROBABLY SOME DAMAGE FROM HURRICANE MICHAEL THAT WAS NOT NOTICED. AND THE BACKSIDE OF IT, THE ROOF RIPPED OFF AGAIN. LOTS OF TRUSS DAMAGE, WALL DAMAGE, WALLS BOWED OUT. THERE'S SOME WOOD LAP SIDING MISSING ON THE WALL AS WELL. JUST THERE'S THE BACK PORTION OF THE GABLE. IT'S KIND OF FLIPPED UP AT THE TRUSSES. AND THERE'S THE BACK HALF. AS I WENT THROUGH THE WOODS THERE, COMPLETELY MISSING, AND ALL THE TRUSSES COLLAPSED INWARD. AND THERE'S TWO ACCESSORIES THAT SIT JUST TO THE REAR OF THAT. AND THEY ARE. AND JUST. BAD SHAPE AS THE, THE HOUSE. AGAIN, MOST OF THE ROOF RIPPED OFF ROTTED TRUSSES AND PURLINS MISSING. THEY'VE KIND OF BEEN PUT TOGETHER MAKESHIFT WITH PIECES FROM THE SIDE OF THE ROAD THERE. AND THAT'S THE SECOND ONE IN THE BACK. MOST OF THE STRUCTURE IS MISSING. HALF OF IT'S THERE HALF'S NOT A LOT OF JUNK AND TRASH SCATTERED ALL AROUND IT. JULY 21ST, 2025 NOTICE HEARING SENT CERTIFIED REGULAR MAIL. THE NOTICES WERE RETURNED UNCLAIMED WITH NO FORWARDING ADDRESS. COPY OF NOTICE OF HEARING WAS POSTED AT THE PROPERTY ON JULY 24TH, 2025 AND MAY 5TH. AGAIN, SAME CONDITION ALL THE WAY TO JUNE. AND JULY 24TH, IT WAS POSTED. OCTOBER 1ST. CHECK. THE BAY COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER AND TAX COLLECTOR DATABASE SHOWS THAT THE PROPERTY OWNERSHIP HAS NOT CHANGED AND TAXES ARE DELINQUENT SINCE 2024. RE INSPECTIONS ARE CONDUCTED BETWEEN MARCH OF 2025 AND SEPTEMBER 2025, AND IT REMAINS STILL IN VIOLATION. NO COMMUNICATION HAVE BEEN RECEIVED FROM FROM THE RESPONDENT TO DATE. AND IS THERE ANY. THAT'S IT. Y'ALL GENERALLY GET ANY KIND OF COMMUNICATION FROM THE LENDER. NOTHING. ALL RIGHT. ARE THOSE THE CAMPERS LOOK LIKE THEY WERE. AT LEAST ONE OF THEM LOOKED LIKE IT WAS PRETTY NEW. IS IT GONE? NO, THEY ARE STILL THERE. WOW. AND IT'S HIT OR MISS SOMETIMES. LIKE I SAID, RIGHT THERE ON AUGUST. IT WAS COOLER OUT THERE, BUT THE STAIRS WERE REMOVED. THERE WAS SOME LITTLE WOODEN STAIRS BECAUSE THE ONES THAT CAME WITH THE CAMPER WERE NOT. I GUESS THEY WERE FOLDED IN. OF COURSE, AS A GORILLA OUT THERE, I HAVE SEEN PEOPLE THERE BEFORE WHEN I WAS DOING THE INSPECTION ON THE OTHER SIDE, BECAUSE I WENT DOWN THE WRONG ROAD AND THEY HIGHTAILED IT INSIDE AND SHUT THE DOOR. SO BUT I'VE HAD NO CONTACT. I'VE KNOCKED ON THE DOOR BEFORE OF THE CAMPER. AC WAS RUNNING AND NOBODY CAME OUT. BUT YOU DIDN'T KNOW? NOBODY'S BEEN CITED FOR [01:45:10] LIVING IN A CAMPER THEN? NO, BUT THEY ARE NO TAGS ON. THEY ARE DERELICT. OKAY. ALL RIGHT. OKAY. BASED ON THE TESTIMONY I'VE HEARD, I'M GOING TO FIND THAT THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT ONE, TWO, TWO, ONE THREE ABBEYVILLE ROAD IN YOUNGSTOWN, IS WITHIN THE UNINCORPORATED AREA BASED COUNTY AND SUBJECT TO THE PROVISIONS OF CHAPTER 17 OF THE CODE VIOLATION ON THE PREMISES IN THE FORM OF UNFIT OR UNSAFE PRIMARY STRUCTURE. ACCESSORY STRUCTURES, TRASH AND JUNK. THE PROPERTY OWNER WILL HAVE A PERIOD TO BRING THE PROPERTY INTO COMPLIANCE OF 30 DAYS BY REMOVING ANY AND ALL TRASH AND JUNK, ONE DERELICT VEHICLE CAN REMAIN ON THE PROPERTY ONLY IF THERE IS ONE REPAIRED, STRUCTURALLY SOUND PRIMARY STRUCTURE ON THE PROPERTY. NO PRIMARY STRUCTURE REMAINS, THEN ALL VEHICLES, BOTH DERELICT AND OPERATIONAL, MUST BE STORED IN AN ENCLOSED STRUCTURE OR REMOVED. YOU HAVE TO ADDRESS THE UNFIT OR UNSAFE STRUCTURE IN THE FOLLOWING MANNER. BY EITHER OBTAINING, APPLYING FOR AND OBTAINING A DEMOLITION PERMIT TO DEMOLISH THE UNFIT OR UNSAFE STRUCTURE IN ANY ALL PROHIBITED ACCESSORY STRUCTURE AS MAY BE DEFINED IN THE LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS, AND REMOVE THE DEMOLITION DEBRIS FROM THE PROPERTY OR, IN THE ALTERNATIVE, REPAIR ALL UNFIT OR UNSAFE STRUCTURES IN THE FOLLOWING MANNER. SUBMIT A COMPLETE BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION TO THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT AND THAT APPLICATION HAS GOT TO INCLUDE A FULL STRUCTURAL REPORT AND COMPLETE SET OF STRUCTURAL REPAIR DRAWINGS FROM A FLORIDA LICENSED AND REGISTERED DESIGN PROFESSIONAL TO CODE ENFORCEMENT. SUBMIT A DETAILED ACTION PLAN, INCLUDING TIME FRAMES OUTLINING THE NECESSARY REPAIRS FOR THE STRUCTURE TO CODE ENFORCEMENT, ALL REQUIRED PERMITS AND ENGINEERING PLANS MUST GO THROUGH THE PLAN REVIEW PROCESS BEFORE THE PERMITS WILL ISSUE. ALL PERMIT INSPECTIONS HAVE GOT TO BE COMPLETED BY BAY COUNTY BUILDERS SERVICES OR A DESIGNEE. REPAIRS HAVE GOT TO BE MADE IN ACCORD WITH THE ACTION PLAN AND THE STRUCTURAL REPORT. ALL BUILDING PERMIT INSPECTIONS HAVE GOT TO BE COMPLETED, AND ALL PERMITS MUST BE FINALIZED IN ORDER FOR THE REPAIRS TO BE DEEMED COMPLETE. IF AT ANY TIME THE REQUIRED PERMITS UNDER THIS ORDER EXPIRE OR BECOME VOID FOR ANY REASON, IT SHALL BE DEEMED A FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH THE TERMS OF THIS ORDER. IT'S THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE RESPONDENT TO CONTACT AND INFORM CODE ENFORCEMENT OF ANY PROGRESS OR DELAYS IN BRINGING THE PROPERTY INTO COMPLIANCE. IF THE RESPONDENT FAILS TO COMPLY WITH THE ABOVE ACTION WITHIN 30 DAYS FROM THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF THE ORDER, A FINE OF $1,000 SHALL BE IMPOSED AND THE FINE WILL BECOME A LIEN ON THE RESPONDENT'S PROPERTY, BOTH REAL AND PERSONAL. LOCATED IN BAY COUNTY, NONCOMPLIANT SHALL BE DEEMED TO HAVE OCCURRED IF THE RESPONDENT OBTAINS A DEMOLITION OR BUILDING PERMIT WITHIN THE TIME FRAME SET FORTH ABOVE, AND THEN ALLOWS IT TO EXPIRE, OR HAS IT BECOME VOID FOR ANY REASON, THAT AGAIN WILL BE DEEMED A DEFAULT AND SHALL BE A FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH THE TERMS OF THIS ORDER. COMPLIANCE HEARING WILL BE HELD ON NOVEMBER THE 19TH. IS THAT OKAY? ALL RIGHT. NEXT IS ITEM E. PROPERTY ADDRESS IS 9315 GOBBLER CIRCLE. SECOND SLIDE IS AN AERIAL VIEW FOR LOCATION PURPOSES. IT IS LOCATED IN THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF BAY COUNTY, COMMONLY KNOWN AS SOUTHPORT BEACH ROAD, EDWARDS ROAD AND THE PROPERTY THERE ON THE THE LEFT. AND UP CLOSE. OR LOOK AT THE PROPERTY. WE'LL BE DISCUSSING THE SINGLE WIDE MOBILE HOME CIRCLED HERE. AND ON DECEMBER 17TH, 2024, INVESTIGATOR JUSTICE DID OBSERVE THIS PROPERTY AND HE FOUND IT IN VIOLATION. 17 DASH TWO IN THE FORM OF A BLIGHTED MOBILE HOME. JUNK AND OVERGROWTH. THESE ARE SOME OF THE PHOTOS THAT HE TOOK ON DECEMBER 17TH. ON JANUARY 27TH, 2025, INVESTIGATOR TONY BRUNING [01:50:07] WAS ASSIGNED THIS CASE AND HE IS HERE TO TESTIFY. TONY BURNHAM, BAY COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT ON JANUARY 27TH, 2025, I INSPECTED THE PROPERTY. AND SOME OF THE THE JUNK HAD BEEN TAKEN CARE OF, BUT THERE'S STILL SOME OUT THERE. IT REMAINS IN VIOLATION. ON JANUARY 28TH, 2025. NOTICE VIOLATION FOR BLIGHTED WAS SENT, CERTIFIED AND REGULAR MAIL TO THE OWNER OF RECORD USING THE ADDRESS 1990. TALIBAN TRAIL HAVANA, FLORIDA 32333. THE NOTICE WAS DELIVERED TO THE RESPONDENT ON FEBRUARY 3RD, 2025, AND ON MARCH 14TH, 2025. INSPECTION WAS CONDUCTED BY INSPECTOR THORPE. AGAIN, INSPECTOR THORPE WAS ABLE TO GO TO 9315 GOBBLER CIRCLE SINGLE WIDE MOBILE HOME THAT HAS HAD SEVERAL ADDITIONS ATTACHED TO IT. NON PERMITTED THAT WERE DIRECTLY ATTACHED TO THE EXTERIOR WALL. IN 2022 TO 23, THE TWO REAR ADDITIONS WERE CONSTRUCTED AND ATTACHED WITHOUT PERMITS. BETWEEN 23 AND 24 OF FRONT ADDITION WAS ALSO ATTACHED WITHOUT PERMITS. AS YOU CAN SEE THERE, THERE'S THE FRONT ADDITION, INADEQUATE FOOTERS AND ADDITION SUPPORTS. THEY JUST USE FOUR BY FOURS SITTING ON THE GROUND. SOME WERE PARTIALLY PLACED IN THE GROUND, BUT NO FOOTERS. SPRAY FOAM WAS USED BETWEEN THE GAPS. INSTEAD OF TAKING SIDING OFF, THEY JUST LAID THE WALL OVER THE SIDING. AND THERE'S THE INADEQUATE FOOTERS IN THE BOTTOM. THAT'S THE LEFT SIDE OF THE MOBILE HOME. YOU CAN SEE THERE'S A LARGE ADDITION AS WELL ON THE BACK. AGAIN, IT'S PRETTY MUCH THE SAME CONDITION AS THE FRONT, SAME BUILD WRAPPED IN TYVEK. AND NO, NO FINISHED WALL COVERING. AND THEN THERE'S A SMALLER ADDITION THAT WAS PLACED ON THE REAR. THERE'S A DECK IN BETWEEN THOSE TWO ADDITIONS IN THE REAR, NO HANDRAILS ON IT. THE DECK WAS HEAVILY ROTTED AS WELL. THERE YOU GO. IT WAS VISIBLE THROUGH THE ONE END OF THE MOBILE HOME. YOU CAN SEE THEY TOOK THE WALLS OUT FOR THE BATHROOM. IT'S GUTTED. SHEETROCK, ELECTRICALS PULLED PLUMBING'S BEEN PULLED AND CAPPED IN SOME AREAS. NO FLOOR COVERING. MECHANICAL REGISTERS HAVE BEEN PULLED OUT OF THE FLOOR AS WELL. IT SITS UNFIT, UNSAFE, UNPERMITTED WORK FOR THIS MOBILE HOME. ON MARCH 17TH, 2025, AN AMENDED NOTICE OF VIOLATION FOR UNFIT UNSAFE STRUCTURE WAS SENT, CERTIFIED AND REGULAR MAIL TO THE OWNER. RECORD USING ADDRESS. 1990 TALIBAN TRAIL, HAVANA, FLORIDA 32333 THE CERTIFIED NOTICE RETURNED UNCLAIMED. THE REGULAR MAIL DID NOT RETURN. ON MARCH 28TH, 2025, THE PROPERTY OWNER, ALEXANDRIA HORNSBY, CALLED BAY COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT TO ADVISE SHE RECEIVED THE NOTICE OF VIOLATION ON MARCH 31ST 31ST, 2025. I SPOKE WITH ALEXANDRIA HORNSBY BY PHONE AND WE DISCUSSED THE VIOLATION TO THE MOBILE HOME AS WELL AS THE PROPERTY. ON JUNE 23RD, 2025, I INSPECTED THE PROPERTY, REMAINED IN VIOLATION DURING THIS INSPECTION. I DID OBSERVE THE OVERGROWTH HAD BEEN CUT AND MOST OF THE JUNK HAD BEEN TAKEN CARE OF REMOVED. SEPTEMBER 3RD, 2025 RE INSPECT THE PROPERTY. IT REMAINS IN VIOLATION. SEPTEMBER 4TH, 2025 NOTICE VIOLATION NOTICE HEARING WAS SENT, CERTIFIED AND REGULAR MAIL TO THE OWNER. RECORD USING ADDRESS 1990 TALIBAN TRAIL, HAVANA, FLORIDA 32333. THE CERTIFIED NOTICE RETURNED UNCLAIMED. THE REGULAR MAIL DID NOT RETURN. SEPTEMBER 25TH, 2025 I POSTED THE PROPERTY ON THAT DAY, AS WELL AS THE BAY COUNTY GOVERNMENT CENTER. ON OCTOBER 6TH, 2025. I INSPECTED THE REINSPECT THE PROPERTY. IT REMAINS IN VIOLATION. I DID TAKE NOTE THAT THE FRONT ADDITION IT START TAKING IT APART, DEMOLISHING IT. THERE ARE NO PERMITS AT ALL AND THIS CASE IS SCHEDULED FOR COMPLIANCE HEARING ON NOVEMBER 19TH, 2025 AT 1 P.M. REFRIGERATOR AND DRYER LOOKS [01:55:05] LIKE A DRYER. YEAH. IT LOOKS LIKE THEY BOARDED UP THE BACK WINDOW. RIGHT. AND I CHECKED THIS MORNING. IT'S THE SAME PROPERTY OWNER THAT OWNS IT. THAT'S THE WAY IT LOOKS THIS MORNING. PRETTY MUCH. WELL, ON MONDAY, MONDAY, OCTOBER 6TH. OKAY. ALL RIGHT. BASED ON THE. WELL, LET ME ASK YOU, WHEN SHE CALLED THIS ALEXANDRIA, WHEN SHE CALLED, DID SHE INDICATE. ANY PLANS OTHER OR DID SHE TELL YOU THAT THEY WERE GOING TO START DOING THIS? ABSOLUTELY. NO. OKAY. ALL RIGHT. OKAY. BASED ON THE TESTIMONY I'VE HEARD IN THE EXHIBITS I'VE SEEN, I'M GOING TO FIND THAT THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 9315 GOBBLER CIRCLE IN SOUTHPORT, IS WITHIN THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF BAY COUNTY AND SUBJECT TO THE PROVISIONS OF CHAPTER 17 OF THE CODE, THAT NOTICE WAS GIVEN TO THE RESPONDENT. SHE HAS CONTACTED CODE ENFORCEMENT. THERE HAS BEEN POSTING OF THIS HEARING BY. ON THE PREMISES, AND I ASSUME THAT THE MAYBE THE COUNTY CENTER AND BY MAIL. THERE IS A VIOLATION OF 1702 ON THE PREMISES IN THE FORM OF AN UNFIT OR UNSAFE MOBILE HOME AND JUMP THE RESPONDENT SHALL HAVE A PERIOD OF 30 DAYS TO BRING THE PROPERTY INTO COMPLIANCE BY REMOVING ANY AND ALL. JUNK ON THE PREMISES. ADDRESS THE UNFIT OR UNSAFE MOBILE HOME IN THE FOLLOWING MANNER. APPLY FOR AND OBTAIN A DEMOLITION PERMIT TO DEMOLISH THE UNFIT OR UNSAFE MOBILE HOME AND ANY AND ALL PROHIBITED ACCESSORY STRUCTURES AND OR ADDITIONS TO THE MOBILE HOME, AND REMOVE THAT DEMOLITION DEBRIS FROM THE PROPERTY OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE, REPAIR THE UNFIT OR UNSAFE MOBILE HOME IN THE FOLLOWING MANNER. SUBMIT A COMPLETE BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION TO THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT AND THAT APPLICATION MUST INCLUDE THE MOBILE HOME MANUFACTURERS SPECIFICATIONS FOR THAT SPECIFIC MODEL OF MOBILE, HOME OR ENGINEERING PLANS AND BLUEPRINTS TO SHOW THAT THERE IS A DEVIATION FROM THE ORIGINAL HOME. ALL THAT GOES TO CODE ENFORCEMENT, REPAIRING OR REMODELING OF A MOBILE HOME OR MANUFACTURED HOME REQUIRES THE USE OF MATERIAL AND DESIGN EQUIVALENT TO THE ORIGINAL CONSTRUCTION. THE STRUCTURE WITHIN THE SCOPE OF THIS REQUIREMENT WILL INCLUDE, BUT IS NOT LIMITED TO, THE ROOF SYSTEM, WALL SYSTEM, FLOOR SYSTEM, WINDOWS AND EXTERIOR DOORS OF THE MOBILE OR MANUFACTURED HOME ELECTRICAL AND PLUMBING REPAIR MUST BE DONE USING MATERIALS AND DESIGN EQUIVALENT TO THE ORIGINAL CONSTRUCTION. REPAIRS HAVE GOT TO BE MADE BY PERSON DESIGNATED AND DEFINED IN FLORIDA STATUTE SECTION 320 .8245 PERIOD. FOR A DETAIL ACTION PLAN HAS GOT TO BE SUBMITTED, INCLUDING THE TIME FRAMES OUTLINING THE NECESSARY REPAIRS FOR THE STRUCTURE TO THE CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION. ALL REQUIRED PERMITS AND MANUFACTURE SPECIFICATIONS, ENGINEERING PLANS OR AND OR BLUEPRINTS HAVE GOT TO GO THROUGH THE PLAN REVIEW PROCESS BEFORE THE PERMITS WILL ISSUE. ALL PERMIT INSPECTIONS HAVE GOT TO BE COMPLETED BY BAY COUNTY BUILDERS SERVICES OR A DESIGNEE. REPAIRS MUST BE MADE IN ACCORD WITH THE ACTION PLAN AND THE STRUCTURAL REPORT. ALL BUILDING PERMIT INSPECTIONS HAVE GOT TO BE COMPLETED AND PERMITS FINALIZED IN ORDER FOR THE REPAIRS TO BE DEEMED COMPLETE. IF ANY TIME THE REQUIRED PERMITS UNDER THIS ORDER EXPIRE OR BECOME VOID FOR ANY REASON, IT SHALL BE DEEMED A FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH THE TERMS OF THIS ORDER. IT'S THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE RESPONDENT TO CONTACT AND INFORM CODE ENFORCEMENT OF PROGRESS OR DELAYS IN BRINGING THE PROPERTY INTO COMPLIANCE. IF THE RESPONDENT FAILS TO COMPLY WITH THE TERMS OF THIS ORDER WITHIN THE 30 DAYS, THERE WILL BE A FINE OF $1,000. THE FINE SHALL BECOME A LIEN ON THE RESPONDENT'S PROPERTY, BOTH REAL AND PERSONAL. LOCATED IN BAY COUNTY, NONCOMPLIANCE SHALL BE DEEMED TO HAVE OCCURRED IF THE RESPONDENT OBTAINS EITHER A DEMOLITION OR A BUILDING PERMIT WITHIN THE TIME FRAME SET FORTH, [02:00:06] AND THEN ALLOWS IT TO EXPIRE, OR HAS IT BECOME VOID FOR ANY REASON AGAIN, AT THAT POINT, IT WILL BE DEEMED A FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH THE TERMS OF THIS ORDER. THERE WILL BE A COMPLIANCE HEARING ON NOVEMBER THE 19TH AT 1 P.M. IN THESE PREMISES. OKEY DOKEY. OKAY. ITEM F AS IN FRANK, THIS IS THE POST-HEARING COMPLIANCE REPORT. THIS IS 2627 AND AVENUE. IT WAS FOUND IN VIOLATION OF UNFIT UNSAFE. AND ON SEPTEMBER 15TH. MOVED. AND THEY ARE IN COMPLIANCE WITH YOUR ORDER. OKAY. BASED ON THE TESTIMONY I'VE HEARD AND THE EXHIBITS I'VE SEEN IN THE FORM OF PHOTOGRAPHS, I'M GOING TO FIND THAT THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 2627 AND AVENUE, PANAMA CITY BEACH, HAS BEEN BROUGHT INTO COMPLIANCE IN THIS CASE, WILL BE CLOSED. OKAY. LAST ITEM IS ITEM I. PROPERTY ADDRESS IS 3605 EAST ORLANDO ROAD. THIS IS A FINAL HEARING. COMPLIANCE HEARING WAS HELD BY THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE ON JUNE 18TH, 2025 AND WAS FOUND RESPONDENT FAILED TO COMPLY WITH THE FIRST ORDER AT THE HEARING HELD ON MAY 14TH, 2025. THE RESPONDENT DID APPEAR AT THE HEARING. PHOTOS OF THE PROPERTY ARE INTRODUCED INTO EVIDENCE EXHIBIT A AND CONTAINED IN THE CASE FILE. MAGISTRATE DIRECTED STAFF TO ABATE THE NUISANCE AND ALL INSULIN COSTS OF ENFORCEMENT TO CONSTITUTE A LEAN AGAINST THE REAL PROPERTY ON WHICH THE VIOLATION EXISTED, AND UPON ANY OTHER REAL PERSONAL PROPERTY OWNED BY RESPONDENT. COPY OF THE ORDER IS INTRODUCED INTO EVIDENCE AS EXHIBIT B AND CONTAINED IN THE CASE FILE. JUNE 10TH AN ASBESTOS SURVEY WAS COMPLETED AT THE COST OF $800. ON JUNE 18TH, 2025, A NOTICE OF INTENT WAS SENT, CERTIFIED AND REGULAR MAIL TO THE PROPERTY OWNER AND OTHER INTERESTED PARTIES. ON JUNE 26TH, A PRE-BID INSPECTION WAS COMPLETED AND AS YOU CAN SEE, PROPERTY REMAINED IN VIOLATION. THE PROPERTY WAS CLEANED BY A COMPANY CONTRACTED BY THE COUNTY AT A COST OF $2,312, AND ON AUGUST 7TH, 2025 WAS FOUND TO BE IN COMPLIANCE. ON AUGUST 9TH, THE NOTICE OF FINAL HEARING WAS SENT. A CHECK WAS RECEIVED IN THE AMOUNT FULL AMOUNT OF $3,112 THAT INCLUDED THE ASBESTOS SURVEY. AND SO IT IS OUR RECOMMENDATION THAT THE MAGISTRATE DETERMINED THAT THE PROPERTY IS NOW IN COMPLIANCE WITH YOUR ORDER. OKAY. BASED ON THE TESTIMONY I'VE HEARD, THE EXHIBITS I'VE SEEN FORM OF PHOTOGRAPHS INTRODUCED INTO EVIDENCE. I'M GOING TO BEVERLY. DON'T RUN OFF. LET ME ASK YOU. I WANT TO ASK YOU ABOUT ONE THING BEFORE YOU GET. I'M GOING TO FIND THAT THE PROPERTY IS IN COMPLIANCE, THAT THE COST OF ABATEMENT ALONG WITH THE SURVEY ASBESTOS SURVEY HAS BEEN PAID IN FULL. IN THIS CASE, SHOULD BE CLOSED. * This transcript was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.